It happens to all of us! My latest tale of woe.

Gonodactylus

Premium Member
Got to bed last night around midnight and was well into REM when the phone rang. It was 1:30 am and a student in my lab was calling to say that one of the 100 gal. tanks in the main lab was leaking. (Take note: students should be in the lab at 1:30 am on a Monday morning.) I figured it was a leaky hose connection or a skimmer overflow and told him that I would be in at 6:30 to take a look. He seemed to think that it was more serious, but I assured him that it would be alright. I was too far gone with too much left over turkey to do much more.

After 15 minutes of staring at the ceiling, I realized that I was not going to get back to sleep and by then I had figured out that it was probably my large Lysiosquillina maculata tank housing a 30 cm pair that I had had for three years. They were in a large u-shaped burrow in a partitioned 40 cm sand bed. Worse yet, I was temporarily storing 4 blue-rings in the other part of the tank.

I dragged myself out of bed, dressed, and drove to campus. There was a stream of water running out of one corner of the tank and about 40 gal of water on the floor soaking boxes, file cabinet, etc. The lab has floor drains, but this tank was in the one spot that did not have one. The powerheads and skimmer were running dry, so I pulled them. The blue-rings were each in a 1 gallon plastic jar with small holes, but I never put holes in the bottom inch, so they has enough water to survive. They were moved to another large tank. I started bailing out water and when the level got down to about 20 cm, the leak pretty much stopped. The silicone sealant had failed, but only the top half of the joint I could spend the rest of the night digging out a couple of hundred pounds of sand so that I could get to the PVC burrow in the bottom housing the Lysios, or I could stabilize the leak and leave them until morning. Fortunately, L. maculata often remain in burrows at low tide that are partially exposed and they can do well for hours in stagnant, really nasty water. I remembered several years ago buying a set of 30 inch cabinet makes clamps that I thought might come in handy building tanks. I dug around the soggy boxes under the tables holding our tanks and found them still in their box. It was an easy task to clamp the joint and stop the leak completely. The canister filter was still running, so I switched the outflow to the sand size of the tank containing the burrow so that the animals would get filtered, oxygenated water, did a quick mop of the lab, and got home by 3:30.

I came in this morning at 6:30 and the Lysios were fine as were the blue-rings. Now I get to spend the day digging out the sand and installing a new tank. Such is the life of a marine biologist. I guess the moral of the story is that all tanks fail - eventually - and when they do, it will be at the worst possible time.

Roy
 
Dr. Roy,

I just had a 40 gal reef tank fail, with luckily only about five or so gallons ending up on the floor. I feel your pain!

I am happy that you were able to save all of the livestock! I know you've had those L. maculata a long time. We had a similar experience. The only loss was a cleaner shrimp -- and that was because it got eaten when we threw it into our larger tank!

Regards,
Dan
 
My 110 busted open again...yes again. I tore it down for good when it happened a few months ago. Didnt get any water on the carpet this time. The first time it busted though I got about 80 gallons of water on the carpet! I was doing a test run of the tank to make sure there were no plumbing leaks and to make sure all of my returns worked properly. Filled it up, walked away...5 minutes later my roommate says "Uh oh" and before I could answer the entire bottom seam came un-done. The last time around I noticed salt creap at the bottom left corner, not wanting to take any chances I tore it down and put my fish in my 30 gal reef that I was hoping to get another Peacock for...Just found a nice O.S. for $40 too
 
Man that's a real bummer guys... Bad time of the year too...

This brings up a good question though. Of all those who had seals fail, how long do you guys estimate tank seals to be good for in SW environments?
 
From what I can gather, a well-built glass or acrylic tank will last "indefinitely". Most glass tank fractures are the result of an unleveled tank (which strains a seam) or a tank that is not on an absolutely flat surface (puts torque on one sheet of the glass). Most acrylic tank ruptures are the result of manufacturing defects -- a well-made acrylic tank is literally one solid piece of plastic. The seams are as strong as the walls.

Of course, in this forum, we have another tank danger -- raptorial impacts! :)

Dan
 
My acrylic was an old tank given to me by my boss. He had it for years then when he moved he tore it down and had it in storage for a year or two...I think during that time the seal deteriorated...None of my other tanks have ever failed on me. I had a 55 gallon with a chip about 1 inch long, 3/8 inch wide and about a 1/8 - 1/4 inch deep right on a seam and it never failed...I ran that tank for 3 years...though it was fresh water
 
This tank was one of four identical 100 gal glass aquaria purchased new in 1994. All have been in continuous operation over the past 13 years. The other three are fine. I think the difference was that this tank was being used for Lysiosquillina and was partitioned with a couple of hundred pounds of sand being held by braces against the front wall. this obviously creates more strain than just the pressure of the water.

Roy
 
Dr Roy, I think you might be on to something with the weight of the sand putting pressure on the side seams. was babysitting a friends coral farm and the same thing happened with a 220 with a DSB, side seam started splitting.
 
Back
Top