Kolorscape playsand

Kap212

New member
Well my local reef club is having a DIY rock party this weekend, and I went out to purchase my supplies today. My local Home Depot has Kolorscape white playsand in stock BUT it states right on the bag not for use in aquariums. Does anyone have experience with this? Or know what the scoop is? I was under the impression that Southdown, was now called Kolorscape and is safe to use?!??!

Thanks for any feedback
Greg
 
That is exactly what I use for a DSB in my sump. I was a little scared to use it, but tons of people told me it would be fine. Including a few in my local club. I have been using it for about 6 months and all is well for me and my tank.

Have fun!
 
Thanks for the info. When I say that on the bag I balked a little, and didn't wanna take a chance before I got some feedback.

Thanks Greg
 
I picked two bags up yesterday at HD. One Kolorscape and one Durascape. I assume they are the same but I wanted to see. I'm going to try the Fizz test on it tonight. I just picked up some vinegar. From what I understand, this is perfectly safe to use. I also hear not to wash it.

BTW, I've also read that the Old Castle and Southdown also read "Not For Aquarium Use".

Let me know how you like it.
 
They always put "Not For Aquarium Use" label on playsand. It's a liability safe guard in case some schmuck decides to want to sue them for causing problems in his tank.
 
ive been looking everywhere for the right sand at HD.still coming up with nothing.ive been from atlanta up to maryland looking at stores that ive been working at.very frustrating to say the least.can someone post a pic of the bag they are using?
 
From what I understand about Kolarscape sand (and many other products), they are not the same everywhere in the country because they are obtained from local sources. That is, HD in California is not going to buy sand quarried in New Jersey and ship it cross country. They buy the sand locally and have it packaged for them. So the HD by me in upstate NY has Kolarscape playsand that IS CALCITE while another HD somewhere else may have the exact same bag with the same SKU number and it is NOT CALCITE. So a picture of my sand with the SKU number may not really help because you may be able to find the exact same bag but it does not have to contain the same sand.

The technical definition of "sand" from a geologic standpoint is related to grain size not composition. The bags can say sand and be composed of any combination of minerals but still be "sand".

This is another reason for all the warning labels "Not for use in an aquarium", "Do not use for concrete, mortor, or structual purposes".

These are just generic labels because the sand can be almost any non-toxic substance. In California "Playsand" cannot have a silica content above some threshold without a warning label that it may contain silica because breating silica dust MAY lead to lung desease. So rather than test every quarry to see what the silica content is they just put the warning on everything. Whether it has silica in it or not.

I recently read an article about expiration dates on over the couter medications. The article said that the regulations state that the drug must have 90% (?) of its effectiveness by the expiration date. So the drug company takes some druglets it sit 2 years, tests it, and sees it still has 99% effectiveness. It passed the test so the compnay says 2 years shelf life because it meets the regulation. The drug may actually still be 90% effective 20 years later, but it was never tested after 20 years. They just label things to meet the requirements. But, i digress..

Dave
 
ther is a white sand that ive seem at different toy stores. it is sold as "tropical play sand" or similar. it is beach sand and white. but white isnt everything. i was at a job site that needed white mortar for bricking. and they had the purest white sand in a pile about 6' high. but it didnt pass the fizz test.
 
The minerals calcite and aragonite (both calcium carbonate) react easily with mild acid. When placed in a mild acid (such as vinegar) calcite and aragonite will "fizz" so many people refer to it as the fiz test or acid test.

Many people will only use calcium carbonate materials in a marine tank. However, most experts will say that there is nothing wrong with using regular silica sand.

Silica will not leach out into the system significantly and calcite and aragonite add lttle or no buffering that many people state.

What should be more important is grain size and appearance.

Dave
 
Here's a pic of the kolorscape I used in my 90g for awhile. I eventually decided that I wanted to go with a SSB, and would rather just go for the "good stuff" since it looks whiter to me.
FYI, it did pass the fizz test for me. While not the extreme amount of bubbles I expected, it was certainly fizzing.
IMG_1498.JPG
 
Back
Top