you take the good with the bad.
We have 4 in our area that does salt and reef.
shop #1, the owner knows very little about keeping salt and reef (but is honest enough to tell you that, keeps cichlids). Good range and ok pricing.
shop #2, a bit more expensive, but nothing beats the reefer who has been in the hobby for 25 years that owns it. Range can be hit and miss sometimes, but at least we get a discount there (wife breeds guppies, and we supply them for store credit). Has a worker that likes to boast that he spent over $100,000 setting up his saltwater in 12 months (nice guy to talk to, but I prefer to ask the owner questions). Recently had an issue with their RO machine and increased phosphates, straight up with it and called around to find another supply for me. I actually intend to keep buying my RO and NSW from this particular shop because of their honesty and help. They are also happy to hold on to coral that I show an interest in because I invariably buy it lol.
Shop #3, only just discovered it. Limited salt/coral range, but pricing is good. Have been warned not to trust advice people from there, but I don't know them well enough to form my own opinion.
Shop #4, the most expensive, but very knowledgeable people there. Has a 15 year old reef tank on display that always looks impressive, and the owner has about 25 years in the hobby (asked him how to knock nitrates to zero, his response was that the tank in the shop when first setup had to be over 100 ppm for him to worry about it, and over the years it has changed, theirs actually runs at 5 - 10 ppm and it is looking brilliant). Has put up with many of my questions as I entered the hobby, including suggesting strongly against buying fish that will not go well in my tank (noob mistakes lol) and was happy to lose a sale. Not that they have though, I still poke around in there and usually get something
One thing I have learned though is to keep google handy and look things up before money changes hands. I found a nice, sexy looking nudibranch the other day, the price was right, asked if it was ok for reef and got the response "yeah, should be", so I googled it. It may have been reef safe, but there was some questions as to whether or not it would munch on coral. So based on $35 for a nudibranch or several hundred dollars of coral, the nudibranch stayed there.
When looking for advice, remember this with many people (from the sunscreen song):
"Whereas the rest of my advice has no basis more reliable
Than my own meandering experience, I will dispense this advice now"
And besides, LFS #2 as described above becomes a meeting place for salties and reefers. It annoys my wife no end when we spend a couple of hours in there chatting away with random people, comparing notes, showing off pics and sharing ideas
