Managing Algae

Sk8r

Staff member
RC Mod
So you had this pristine white tank with beautiful rock shapes...
and then the green stuff took over.
Yep. That's the way it is.
So let's understand what it is, what causes it, and what you do about it that actually works.
1. What is it?
a) pest microalgaes, green film, hair, bubble.
b) floating and rooted macroalgaes, among them cheatomorpha, halimeda, caulerpa
c) things that only look like algae: cyanobacteria, diatoms

a) and b) depend on phosphate. Eliminate phosphate, and you eliminate these algaes. Should you test for phosphate? Surprisingly, no. Not ordinarily. The test costs money and only tells you what you can see when you look at your tank: you have phosphate if you have a) and b) algaes. If they're growing like crazy, you have a LOT of phosphate.

Where does phosphate get into your tank? 1) sand and rock: it binds with sand and rock, and dissolves into saltwater, so there you are. 2) tapwater: if you're not using ro/di, the stuff is likely not only coming into your tank, it's building up and up, because it doesn't evaporate. 3) fishfood that has algae in it.
To get rid of phosphate: 1) use ro/di exclusively; 2) patience---after it leaches out of your rocks, water changes and especially a fuge will rid you of it. 3) a fuge or GFO (granulated ferric oxide) reactor. You set this up, toss the waste or overgrowth, and you've exported the spare phosphate. Ironically, you can even sell it to another reefer, as algae. BUT: use cheato as your fuge algae, never caulerpa!!!!!!

OK: now to fuges and rooted and non-rooted macroalgaes. Avoid caulerpa like the plague. It's illegal in California, it's killing life in the Med, and it reproduces by 1. runner 2 fragment 3 spores, so it CAN get through your fuge pump; it's poisonous and nasty and most things won't eat it. One fish will: the onespot rabbit, but that fish is large (up to 10 inches) and venomous itself, and rowdy. I really, really advise against caulerpa, no matter how cheap and local. Halimeda is a stony rooted macroalgae: I've never found it to be a problem, except it's persistent and nothing I know eats it. Cheatomorpha is a floating macro that is ideal for a fuge: it reproduces much more slowly than caulerpa, and DOES NOT ROOT in your rock. It also aerates very, very efficiently. I keep my fuge lit 24/7.

Now to NON-ALGAES that look like algaes. The red blush on your sand (brown in some lighting) is cyanobacteria, one of the oldest lifeforms on earth. Look it up. It's a read. To get rid of it, first have a really good skimmer; then turn the lights out on your tank 3 days a month (1 day of actinic only, if you have MH lighting, total of 4 days.) It won't hurt your reef. But it will kill this stuff, which has only 3 life requirements: water, oxygen, and sunlight. Sunlight is all you can rob it of safely. Since it is also the origin of chloroplasts in all living green plants, forget trying to avoid it getting into your tank---just deal with it as it shows up. And avoid having slanted sunlight hitting your tank: this stuff had its heyday in the era of the Permian Extinction, when weird-spectrum sunlight was getting through the clouds. It loves that situation. Keep sunlight from your tank in all seasons, or expect to have a little of this show up. Do NOT use Red Slime remedy as a beginner: that rides beginner's luck to the max, and you can can crash your tank with it if you make a mistake or if your skimmer isn't what it ought to be. A cyano outbreak is soooo minor, and does no real harm, bad as it looks: don't panic. Take the long route, and you'll beat it within a few months.

And diatoms: animacules, as cyano is sorta plant/sorta animal, this stuff is little microscopic animals. A baby-poop-brown fluff or sheet or stain on the sand. Treat it much the same as cyano, but this stuff DOES like phosphate particularly well, so a fuge will help.
 
The deal with a cleanup crew is that they poo the phosphate back into the water, so while they will keep the growth in check, they won't remove the phosphate, which is algae fertilizer. The only way to remove phosphate is to take something out of the tank, which is easiest done in a fuge: the more macro algae you toss (or sell), the more phosphate is leaving your tank.
 
Sk8r, since you posted this I have a question.

I have hair algae in my 55gal. The tank is about 5 months old and the HA showed up maybe a month ago. I have about 4-6" fine sandbed, about 60lbs of rock (4 large pieces), 4 little fish (2 clarkii's, YWG, tailspot blenny). No fuge, no other filtration and no macro. I use only RO/DI and do my best not to overfeed. My cuc is a couple of shrimp, a couple of hermit crabs, and about 6 assorted snails.

Since the HA started I increased WC's to weekly and doubled the volume, so I now do 10% weekly. I also remove any of the algae I can easily get at before each WC (ie: scrape it off the back wall). I am not interested in adding a fuge or any hang-on filtration, and haven't found an attractive way to include a large enough in-tank fuge area to make it worthwhile. I do not want to add a fish to eat it, but wouldn't mind increasing the CUC as long as they can be sustained once the algae is gone. I am happy to do extra maintenance, but would rather not start dosing anything (this is meant to be a 'low maintenance' tank... the 'high maintenance' one is a different story).

Since I upped the WC's and started paying close attention to feeding, the algae doesn't seem to be getting any worse, but it hasn't really receeded much. Do you have any suggestions for anything else I can do to speed up it's exit from the system?

Thanks
 
Re the HA---phosphate does exist in high amounts in some fish food, but I'm thinking possibly your delayed outbreak involves your 'large pieces' of rock, where the layer of phosphate in the rock has just gotten tapped. Courage. It will get better. And I also have a 54g so I know where you're coming from on the fuge: no room for one. A couple of suggestions. 1. do one anyway on a closed loop...ie, a pump in your sump that takes water from a fuge and delivers water back to the fuge at the same rate. Or a pump set in the fuge, etc: a Maxijet 1200 is perfectly adequate. A fuge can be quite decorative, a 24/7 lit tank with sand and live rock that's just a macro jungle with sand, rock, some interesting crabs, fanworms, and other fauna. That's one method, a 20 gallon fuge set on a shelf near your tank. The other is much more hideable, but more prone to leakage: a gfo (granulated ferric oxide) reactor set in your sump, or 'dry' outside (I'd set it in a a dry bucket in case) using a small pump in the sump. A gfo reactor is about the same price as a fuge setup, about 50.00, plus pump. But either one will get you relief from the algae. The skimmer probably helps a little, but not enough: it gets mostly amino acids, which froth. But one of those two solutions plus time and water changes will help you. Check your TDS on your ro/di (filters can be bad---though they should last a year!) and otherwise, just do your water changes---eventually those alone would get it, but it's a longer road.
 
Thanks Sk8r. No fuge either on this beast - it sits on top of my china cabinet, so no easy way to add one and I'm really trying to keep clean lines with no extra equipment. I agree the phosphate is probably coming from the rocks. Water changes and patience is the name of the game these days. Once the patience wears thin I'll look at adding a sump/fuge. :D
 
hey, wat does it mean if my cheato isnt floating? Don't remember if it was your tread or another i just read but it said cheato floats. I have a pretty good sized ball I bought about 3 weeks ago and it sits in the corner on the bottom of the sump. I turn it over every other day.
Thanks
 
Re cheato floating. As the ball grows bigger it will tend to, but you may still have to rotate it now and again: I swear the phase where it rolls 'naturally' in the current is brief. Mine is the size of a basketball and does not rotate on its own. Just keep doing what you're doing, and you might, if it starts decomposing on the bottom, prop it on a bit of eggcrate or a spare rock to make sure it gets flow all around---outside of that, if it's green, it's good.
 
That's weird. It can come apart and start shredding through the pump into the display, in which case it's probably done for. The usual issue is light. It's light hungry, doesn't mind being lit 24/7, but you might put a screen of plastic needlepoint canvas (hobby store, yarn dept) between your fuge outflow and the pump to be sure it's not a flow exceeding its cohesiveness...I'm betting you need more or longer-time light.
 
Back
Top