Monterey Aquarium exempt from state waste water ban

ezcompany

Premium Member
I don't know how many of you are recreational anglers, but if you are then you should have heard of the MLPA's going into effect soon. Here is further proof that if you have the money, you can push the law aside. I was a big supporter of this aquarium, but I'm not sure they qualify as stewards of the ocean anymore after reading this.

----------------------------------------------------------------

California Watch


Monterey Bay Aquarium exempted from state wastewater ban

October 25, 2011 | Susanne Rust, California Watch



Mike Baird/FlickrThe Monterey Bay Aquarium, famous for its sea otters, discharges millions of gallons of treated fish, bird and mammal waste into the bay.

Although famous for conservation and its sustainable and environmentally friendly practices, the Monterey Bay Aquarium is also one of the largest wastewater dischargers in the protected Pacific Grove area of the bay.

Last week, the State Water Resources Control Board exempted the aquarium [PDF] from a state ban on dumping wastewater in a marine protected zone.

The board decided the aquarium's conservation and public education benefits far outweigh any dangers posed by the millions of gallons of treated fish, bird and mammal waste it dumps back into the bay.

"œThe Monterey Bay Aquarium's beneficial uses include extensive public outreach and education on the marine environment, basic water quality research, and research to determine the needs and improve the quality of existence for marine life," said David Clegern, a spokesman for the water board.

According to a report [PDF] released by the board earlier this year, the aquarium takes in about 1,400 gallons of seawater a minute, 24 hours a day, every day of the year. It then discharges more than 2 million gallons a day. The system is open, meaning seawater is pumped in and discharged continually.

The board acknowledges the discharge does contain waste, albeit "œat very low levels." The only exceptions noted were copper in one seawater sample and chlorine in others.

Copper is known to be harmful to marine organisms, damaging creatures' gills, livers, kidneys and nervous systems. Chlorine can be lethal to many organisms, including salmon and oysters, at low levels.

"œNone of the seawater samples exhibited toxicity effects," the report's authors wrote. However, storm water runoff from the aquarium contained waste and in some cases exceeded state standards.

Aquarium officials, for their part, say they do everything they can to minimize the harm the aquarium poses to marine life right off its shore. For instance, the aquarium routes all seawater exposed to birds and mammals through ultraviolet sterilization before dumping it back in the bay. This process gets rid of bacteria and other microbes.

Other discharged water, particularly water that has been in contact with exotic species, is run through ozone treatment in order to kill any larvae or eggs that could potentially reach the bay.

And water treated with chemicals or pharmaceuticals is isolated and not released back into the bay.

"œOperating a large public aquarium requires substantial resources and a large staff, and we recognize that our environmental footprint is likewise substantial," aquarium officials wrote in a brochure [PDF] about the aquarium's commitment to sustainable and environmentally friendly practices, called "œStriving for Sustainability."

"We are doing everything we can to minimize our footprint in the ocean," said Ken Peterson, an aquarium spokesman. "There's no doubt it's a challenge."

The aquarium sits next to the Pacific Grove area, a state-designated Area of Special Biological Significance. Since 1983, as part of its Ocean Plan, the state has banned wastewater discharge into any of the 34 designated marine areas.

In 2004, the water board notified the aquarium that it had to cease storm water and other discharges in the protected area or request an exception under the Ocean Plan.

The aquarium sought an exception in 2006, and the state water board prepared a report on the request.

In April of this year, a public meeting was held to consider the exception, and last week, it was finally approved.

"By and large, this exception allows the aquarium to continue being a public aquarium exposing millions of people every year to marine life in the hopes that we can get them interested and concerned about ocean issues," Peterson said. "There is a value in that, and we are pleased it is recognized and valued by the State Water Resources Control Board."
 
I see nothing wrong with what they are doing. They are seeming to be doing all the necessary steps to minimize their impact Remember that this is not human waste we are discussing. The is waste of animals that are sea dwelling. And just to be extra careful, they make sure they take the steps to not introduce bacteria that is foreign to the area.
 
"The only exceptions noted were copper in one seawater sample and chlorine in others.

Copper is known to be harmful to marine organisms, damaging creatures' gills, livers, kidneys and nervous systems. Chlorine can be lethal to many organisms, including salmon and oysters, at low levels."


Don't think the copper will build up over time? I sure think it will.
 
I wish most hobbyists, LFS etc were as thorough as Monterey Bay Aq. esp with copper, caulerpa etc. Lots of folks to direct our ire towards and I would pick a whole lot of others including the petro-chemical/oil/plastics industry b4 Monterey Aquarium. JMO.
 
Anyone who has issues with the Monterey Aquarium better take a look in the mirror and ask themselves what are they dumping down the drain from their own aquarium! I don't know anyone in the hobby who sends their waste off to a toxic dump.
 
Anyone who has issues with the Monterey Aquarium better take a look in the mirror and ask themselves what are they dumping down the drain from their own aquarium! I don't know anyone in the hobby who sends their waste off to a toxic dump.

I agree , Most of us just just drains our water to the sewer and if tge Aquarium did that and dumped their waste on the sewer I bet that wont last a few years.
 
How big is the ocean's biological filtration system? Should be no problem. Never been, looking forward to going someday!
 
I also see nothing wrong as their benefits outweigh dangers by far. It stated copper was found in one test not all. The turnaround rate is large enough to keep the waste at minimal levels consistently. This is a beautiful aquarium and I can't wait to be back there this December.
 
"The only exceptions noted were copper in one seawater sample and chlorine in others.

Copper is known to be harmful to marine organisms, damaging creatures' gills, livers, kidneys and nervous systems. Chlorine can be lethal to many organisms, including salmon and oysters, at low levels."


Don't think the copper will build up over time? I sure think it will.

:fish1:
You highly underestimate the power of the ocean and how large it really is. As hobbyist\, we have to educate ourselves on many aspects of science from Biology to Chemistry and even Physics. It is not difficult to go a step further and look at Oceanography. It is common to use the phrase "The solution to pollution is dilution" and this is exactly what is happening at Monteray Bay. You must also not confuse pollution from humans equal to that coming out of their aquarium exhibits. The ocean has evolved to handle organic biomass from marine organisms in bulk. It has not been able to evolve and adapt to us as rapidly as we have industrialized.

While yes, you would see more organic waste and possible chemical waste added to the bay, I doubt that it would play an effect at all on the HIGHLY productive and diverse ecosystem that is present. It will all most likely be broken down rapidly and dispersed through its trophic levels.

Lots of factors play in to this and I think that the aquarium probably has thought of most of them already! ;)
 
Last edited:
:fish1:
It is common to use the phrase "The solution to pollution is dilution" and this is exactly what is happening at Monteray Bay. You must also not confuse pollution from humans equal to that coming out of their aquarium exhibits. The ocean has evolved to handle organic biomass from marine organisms in bulk. It has not been able to evolve and adapt to us as rapidly as we have industrialized.

+1; nicely put. I think, however, you nailed it when you say the ocean "has not been able to evolve and adapt to us as rapidly as we have industrialized." The massive amounts of toxic chemicals and ridiculous amounts of plastics we put into the ocean are dramatically impacting the ocean's ecosystems. Pacific garbage patch, the increasing number of dead zones and overfishing are just some of the most obvious.

And this is exactly why Monterey Bay Aquarium is such an important resource.
 
“None of the seawater samples exhibited toxicity effects,” the report's authors wrote. However, storm water runoff from the aquarium contained waste and in some cases exceeded state standards.

That statement tells me the waste from the aquariums isn't the issue. Runoff from the property seems to be more of a problem. Not sure how they can address this unless they don't let fluid leaking cars in their parking lots.
 
Back
Top