New Build – 40 gal stocking plan – What do you think?

dndlyon

New member
Hi All!

I'm looking to start back into the hobby after a 10+ year break. So much has changed, and so much hasn't "“ Glad Reef Central is still here (even if I can't remember my original UserName)! I recently obtained a 40 gal (think it's too tall to be a breeder) and a 10 gal (both glass). Eventually, I'm hoping this 40 will be the sump of something larger, but that is way down the road "“ like after I win the PowerBall"¦twice.

I've always kept nano tanks - SPS with a fish or two "“ which is easy when the tanks are in a science lab with the best test kits and water that a lab can buy. This 40 gallon seems HUGE and still not big enough! I've always loved to watch clownfish and their anemones. My nano tanks were always too small to even think about trying this. Lately I've seen so many posts from those of you who are raising fry, that I think I'd eventually like to give this a try. With that being said, that's a looooong ways down the road "“ these tanks don't even have water in them yet! So, here's what I'm thinking:

I'd like to use the 10 gal as a Q tank or a frag tank (or a nursery!), with a larger sump at some point, but it will start out as a 40 gal main tank with 10 gal sump to house the protein skimmer, etc. No one local will drill because I have no idea if it's tempered glass, so I'm going to go with a HOB overflow. I agree! HOBs are difficult, so let's not side track on that. :p

The tank will likely be clean-up crew and LR for a significant time. I'd like the LR formation to have spots for small SPS at the top and sheltered spots lower in the tank. Ideally I'd like to create spots that mix up flow and light providing a few different options for the eventual anemone and maybe some "œshade" for a few mushrooms. Once I feel the system is stable, I'll probably wait another month or two ;) and then add the SPS, and let everything settle in. Then I would add the anemone / clownfish pair, and much later maybe a goby or blenny.

How much flow would you like to see in a tank like this? I've always just used the biggest pumps I could afford, but that was for all SPS and a fish or two. Does that still hold true if I can create flow sheltered areas (that still get enough light)?

Too much bioload (if added slower than molasses in winter)?

If you currently have a 40 gal (or close in size), and you had a "œDo Over" "“ what would you do different?

Thanks for your thoughts! Now that I'm back, I've been lurking for a bit. Excited to be back, and am waiting for the money to build so I can get started"¦Simple questions, but I think I just need to talk to you guys! :wave:
 
I have a 40B and I love the dimensions. If I had a do-over:
- I would have drilled mine and installed an overflow/sump. I'm getting new carpet this spring and I will have to move everything, so I am getting another 40B and drilling it, then turning my current one into a sump.
- I upgraded from a 20g and I used the rock from there and added more. Next time, I will be buying all new dry rock from the same place so they look more cohesive. Then spend the time aquascaping and planning ahead a bit more.

Keep in mind that with a nem, they will move around and sting your coral. So hopefully yours will find a nice home and stay there. Then you can plan your sps around it. :)
 
Not to hang you up,,,:) but not doing a bean animal is a huge regret. Also you can do a search on you tube and they have some videos to show you how to tell if your back galss is tempered or not. Pretty easy to do.
 
Thanks to both of you!

I know the Nem will more than likely wander, but would they actually wander up the rocks? Never thought about that, Rubasu! Thanks for bringing it up!

dpulve - my first post back was actually about the bean animal overflow - asking if it was overkill for a 40 gal. I really want to do it that way, but was told there is no way to tell if the glass is tempered. Thanks for the info on the videos - had no idea. At least I know I don't want the guy who told me he couldn't tell to do the drilling!
 
Yeah, they will sort of go wherever they want until they settle down. (Mine moved to the backside of a rock...so I put the flow in it's direction and it moved again. Then I just kept the lighting/flow the same when I didn't mind the spot that it picked.) Once they find a good spot, they typically stay put.
 
Thanks to both of you!

I know the Nem will more than likely wander, but would they actually wander up the rocks? Never thought about that, Rubasu! Thanks for bringing it up!

dpulve - my first post back was actually about the bean animal overflow - asking if it was overkill for a 40 gal. I really want to do it that way, but was told there is no way to tell if the glass is tempered. Thanks for the info on the videos - had no idea. At least I know I don't want the guy who told me he couldn't tell to do the drilling!

Whoever said that about glass is way off.

Once you know what to look for, following correct method, its somewhat easy to tell if the glass is tempered. Spotting the stress lines in tempered glass is a good indicator. And, have a known piece of tempered glass to compare helps. For example, a glass shelf would be make out of tempered glass. I used the shelf in my fridge.

IMO a Herbie drain is plenty safe for a 40 gallon, if you have a critter/fish protected overflow weir.
 
I have a 40B and I love the dimensions. If I had a do-over:
- I would have drilled mine and installed an overflow/sump. I'm getting new carpet this spring and I will have to move everything, so I am getting another 40B and drilling it, then turning my current one into a sump.

+1

I inherited a freshwater 40 breeder setup. So, of course, the tank is not drilled. To make it worse, the tank is on one of those Petsmart stands that has shelves underneath. Therefore, no room for a sump.

I would also go for a courser grain sand. I have Fuji pink, and it gets cloudy pretty quickly at every water change.
 
Back
Top