In the spirit of bringing a thread back to its theme, I thought I would expand on some thoughts I expressed in the beginning of this thread in relation to the spread of a LumenArc being useful only a foot away from the bulb. The graphs that Sanjay provided sync up with the photo I am about to show. Just to refresh everyone's memory of the graph I listed:
At the surface of the water 18" away from a 400w XM DE 10K bulb showed very little light. My argument is that our coral does not sit on the surface of the water but obviously below it. If you have a 24" deep tank, there will be little light on the bottom 12"-18" away from the bulb. This something that seems to be a non-issue when using the LumenBrights as shown in the PAR tests on several tanks so far.
This photo was taken at a local LFS that has 22" Diamond Light reflectors(much bigger than mini or large Lumenarcs - original design). This particular reflector housed a 400w XM 20K bulb and the bulb was 18" off the water. If you figure it this way the measurements were taken 1" above the surface and 8" below the water. If this bulb had to penetrate 16"-24" of water, I am sure it would not be optimal for an SPS dominant tank.
You will notice that 12" away from the bulb, there is a significant loss of light and 18" away shows absolutely no usable light. This is the point I tried to make to Hahn. The Lumenarcs or Diamond Lights really only provide diffused aesthetic light if spread is important to you. It is very noticeable that the spread from the LumenBrights is more than adequate for most applications. Also, it is important to note that raising the LumenBrights only helps spread and allows for intense lighting where raising a Lumenarc to 16" will not be optimal for SPS Dominat tanks. Lumenarcs must be closer to the surface of the water to provide the intensity that is necessary. Again, this will prove to evaporate more water, heat up you tank quicker, put more UV onto your coral,, leave less room in the canopy for maintenance as well as air circulation. Beign able to raise LumenBrights and still get more than adequate PAR ratings is the real beauty about these reflectors.
Here you go:
I am planning on doing some side by side testing with a Diamond Light and LumenBright to show further the 16% increase that has been claimed by the manufacturer. It will be in the near future. Not sure exactly when I will be able to get everything set up.