I agree. They should deffinately expand alot during the day. I have a green open brain that would not expand at all until I put him in a somewhat more shady spot of the tank. Now it triples in size daily. I'm not sure of the lighting requirments of the red open brains. I do know this---Don't let sand sit on the edge of its soft tissue. I have one that got partially covered from a sand sifter. I let it go a few days thinking the coral should be able to take care of itself. After 3 days I finally reached in and shook it off, and to my dismay there was a big piece of tissue missing. It has since somewhat healed, but you can still see where I messed up on him.