New to Hobby Need Help!!

MikeyWeez

New member
I started my first aquarium 10 months ago. I originally started just to get a cool looking decoration for my house. I quickly realized how much work and investment would be needed to obtain a beautiful home aquarium and instead of shying away I immediately started to appreciate a beautiful aquarium and my passion grew and I decided to make it a great hobby of mine.

I have several advantages to become the owner of a beautiful reef aquarium. The first is that I absolutely have the passion to put the necessary work in to obtaining a healthy, beautiful reef tank. The second is that for the most part I have the time to dedicate to the hobby. The final advantage is that I have the funds to invest to get myself the tank of my dreams. The biggest disadvantage I have is my lack of patience. I really didnt understand the hobby and therefor believed I could simply buy myself into a beautiful aquarium. That has not gone so well. The second disadvantage is the fact that i do have funds to invest and therefor, given the fact I lacked patience, I spent a ton of money on new life when neither me or my tank was ready to sustain it. So I have learned from that and that is why I am finally joining this community. I have learned enough over the past months to consider myself slightly above beginner level and I need to help to go along with my ambition to really get the tank I want.

I currently have a 110 gallon tank. I have a sump with a refugium, large high quality skimmer, and oxide reactor. I am running apex hyrda 52 LED lights. As far as fish, I have a large purple tang, a yellow tang, a small hippo tang, a sailfin tang, 2 clown fish, a bottle nose hawkfish, 4 firefly fish, a large starfish, a blue fish that I cant remember its name, about 9 cleaner crabs, and about 9 cleaner slugs, and a cleaner shrimp. For corals I have a large blasto colony, 4 large zoa colonies, a large hard body brain type coral, 3 alveopora colonies, about 20 polyp frags, 3 stylophora corals, 3 hydrophora corals, toadstool, and a frogspawn, and a few mushrooms.

My current water levels are:

salinity: 1.025-1.025
Nitrate: 0
Phosphate: 0
nitrite
ammonia: <.1
Ka: 10.3
MG: 1500
Ca: 450
temperature: 72

It has been a long joyrney for me in 10 months. I have been through 3 fish "maintenance professionals" Started my aquarium with a fish focused tank in mind. Then switched to a reef tank about 3 months in. I think the biggest problem I have now is I just have put my tank through so many changes and just added a lot of life probably too quickly. About a month ago I moved from a 75 gallon petland tank with an overflow box to a new tank with the water flow system internal. I have added a number of the corals listed above within the past month. About a week ago I noticed my salinity was down around 1.021-1.022 so I did a 40% water change with ro/di water with higher salinity just a few days ago. The salinity has now balanced out right out the perfect level. I feed my corals reef roids 2 x per week. I also have acro power that I put in 2x per week and amino acid concentrate that I put in 1x per day. I feed all of my fish aquadine.

I am concerned howver because every since I did that water change, some of my corals are really not looking great. The weird part is, the harder to keep corals, the sylophoras, the hydrophoras, and a few others that my fish guy said probably wouldnt make it when I ordered them are looking very bright and healthy, however some of the easier corals are not. My toadstool has not fully opened in over a week. I have not seen the little green polyps from it in over a week. My blasto has bee wilting away over the past few days. I got a new torch coral a few days ago that got brown jelly and died 2 days later. My star polyps are not opening up recently. And my other polyp frags are too brown for the most part. I am not sure what the issue is. I have literaly done everything I could for this tank.

I am looking for some help building and maintaining a really spectacular tank. Again, I have the time, the passion, and the money to have one of the nicest tanks in the world. THe only thing I am missing is the profesional guidance to get me there.

Can someone please give me an idea what I need to do better to get these corals healthier? If there is any more information you need then please let me know and I will post it. My first questions I wanted to ask are:
1) what size cleaning crew is necessary for my size tank? I think I am low on cleaners.
2) what are the optimal settings for my LED hyrdo 52 lights? Do I keep them on all night on a lower setting? What is the best setting for all the different light ranges?


Ok, that is a pretty long introduction so I will leave it at that. I really really appreciate any help anyone can offer me. I have literally put over $12,000 into this tank and I have probably wasted at least $8,000 on dead life and shitty equipment. I am ready to work hard and i need some help. Thank you all very much.
 
I started my first aquarium 10 months ago. I originally started just to get a cool looking decoration for my house. I quickly realized how much work and investment would be needed to obtain a beautiful home aquarium and instead of shying away I immediately started to appreciate a beautiful aquarium and my passion grew and I decided to make it a great hobby of mine.

I have several advantages to become the owner of a beautiful reef aquarium. The first is that I absolutely have the passion to put the necessary work in to obtaining a healthy, beautiful reef tank. The second is that for the most part I have the time to dedicate to the hobby. The final advantage is that I have the funds to invest to get myself the tank of my dreams. The biggest disadvantage I have is my lack of patience. I really didnt understand the hobby and therefor believed I could simply buy myself into a beautiful aquarium. That has not gone so well. The second disadvantage is the fact that i do have funds to invest and therefor, given the fact I lacked patience, I spent a ton of money on new life when neither me or my tank was ready to sustain it. So I have learned from that and that is why I am finally joining this community. I have learned enough over the past months to consider myself slightly above beginner level and I need to help to go along with my ambition to really get the tank I want.

I currently have a 110 gallon tank. I have a sump with a refugium, large high quality skimmer, and oxide reactor. I am running apex hyrda 52 LED lights. As far as fish, I have a large purple tang, a yellow tang, a small hippo tang, a sailfin tang, 2 clown fish, a bottle nose hawkfish, 4 firefly fish, a large starfish, a blue fish that I cant remember its name, about 9 cleaner crabs, and about 9 cleaner slugs, and a cleaner shrimp. For corals I have a large blasto colony, 4 large zoa colonies, a large hard body brain type coral, 3 alveopora colonies, about 20 polyp frags, 3 stylophora corals, 3 hydrophora corals, toadstool, and a frogspawn, and a few mushrooms.

My current water levels are:

salinity: 1.025-1.025
Nitrate: 0
Phosphate: 0
nitrite
ammonia: <.1
Ka: 10.3
MG: 1500
Ca: 450
temperature: 72

It has been a long joyrney for me in 10 months. I have been through 3 fish "maintenance professionals" Started my aquarium with a fish focused tank in mind. Then switched to a reef tank about 3 months in. I think the biggest problem I have now is I just have put my tank through so many changes and just added a lot of life probably too quickly. About a month ago I moved from a 75 gallon petland tank with an overflow box to a new tank with the water flow system internal. I have added a number of the corals listed above within the past month. About a week ago I noticed my salinity was down around 1.021-1.022 so I did a 40% water change with ro/di water with higher salinity just a few days ago. The salinity has now balanced out right out the perfect level. I feed my corals reef roids 2 x per week. I also have acro power that I put in 2x per week and amino acid concentrate that I put in 1x per day. I feed all of my fish aquadine.

I am concerned howver because every since I did that water change, some of my corals are really not looking great. The weird part is, the harder to keep corals, the sylophoras, the hydrophoras, and a few others that my fish guy said probably wouldnt make it when I ordered them are looking very bright and healthy, however some of the easier corals are not. My toadstool has not fully opened in over a week. I have not seen the little green polyps from it in over a week. My blasto has bee wilting away over the past few days. I got a new torch coral a few days ago that got brown jelly and died 2 days later. My star polyps are not opening up recently. And my other polyp frags are too brown for the most part. I am not sure what the issue is. I have literaly done everything I could for this tank.

I am looking for some help building and maintaining a really spectacular tank. Again, I have the time, the passion, and the money to have one of the nicest tanks in the world. THe only thing I am missing is the profesional guidance to get me there.

Can someone please give me an idea what I need to do better to get these corals healthier? If there is any more information you need then please let me know and I will post it. My first questions I wanted to ask are:
1) what size cleaning crew is necessary for my size tank? I think I am low on cleaners.
2) what are the optimal settings for my LED hyrdo 52 lights? Do I keep them on all night on a lower setting? What is the best setting for all the different light ranges?


Ok, that is a pretty long introduction so I will leave it at that. I really really appreciate any help anyone can offer me. I have literally put over $12,000 into this tank and I have probably wasted at least $8,000 on dead life and shitty equipment. I am ready to work hard and i need some help. Thank you all very much.
your temp is awful low sitting at 72. I'd say give it some time no telling what was going on with the numbers in your tank with the salinity sitting at 1.021. keep an eye on salinity and alk for the next week and hope for a bounce back
 
For being in it for 10 months, your going too fast.

First, don't take this the wrong way and I'm not the tang police, but you have some very large bio load fish in a tank that can't sustain them long term.

The sailfin and hippo need a much larger tank and should be rehomed ASAP. The purple and yellow are pushing it in that size tank alone. With all of the other fish and inverts that you currently have, a tank crash could happen easily.

I could very well see that keeping water prameters stable would be difficult.

Once again, please don't take this the wrong way. I'm just speaking from experience and want you to have success.

As far as SG keeping it stable, are you running a ATO?
 
Last edited:
U can't just throw money at your tank and make it work. Time to slow down and research before u lose more money.
 
I wouldn't worry about the clean up crew, you have bigger issues to fix.

Water temp is 72 degrees? That's about the lowest it should ever go and then not because you want it there. Get to 76 or 78, I run all 4 of my tanks between 79 and 80.

You have an oxide reactor? I've been in the hobby 12 years and I have no idea what an oxide reactor is?

How did your salinity get down to 1.021? If you are doing regular testing of your water parameters and regular water changes, how in the world did your salinity ever get to 1.021 or .022? And I would NOT have recommended a 40% water change to get the salinity back up in one shot. Stability is your friend.

Your toadstool is a leather. When they get PO'd because of a big swing in a water parameter they often won't put polyps back out for days... even as long as a couple of weeks. You are rushing to hard. Relax.

You are trying with corals that can be hard to keep and you don't have a mature or stable tank. Too much, too exotic, too soon with not enough knowledge.

You have a 110g tank. How big is the sump? How big is the refugium? What do you have in the refugium? How much rock do you have in the system (it's OK to have rock in the sump). Where do you get your water? What salt do you use? How often do you do water parameter tests? Do you do them or do you have "maintenance professionals" doing the testing and work for you? How often do you do water changes and what percentage of water do you change?

I think you need to learn more and do less for the next month and just maintain the tank rather than trying to fix it.

Oh, and what are you currently running your lights at? What power level and for how long? Do they have a moonlight setting for night? The tank doesn't need light at night. Moonlights are for us, not for the guys in the tank.

I don't mean to be critical, but you offered up a very distressing view of what you have been doing so far. You say you have the time, the desire and the money, but from what you have told us, it doesn't sound like you are doing the work necessary to maintain a reef. You may not be far off, but a water temp of 72 and salinity of 1.021 or 22 shows very poor following through on testing and maintenance.

I'm willing to help if I can because I struggled a lot for my first 3 years in the hobby. But I started out smaller and didn't try to get too fancy too fast. But RC and a local club came into my life and it turned things around big time. So I see helping new reefers as my way to 'Pay It Forward.'
 
Last edited:
+1 to all of the above. the only way you can have a awesome tank is to learn how. not to be rude but your making newbie mistakes (we have all been there) rehome those tangs....and focus on balance, slow down and enjoy.
 
I struggle with the impatience too so I can understand. Everything I've learned about this hobby is to take your time. I think one of your advantages, the funds, might prove to be a disadvantage. You may see an algae outbreak and start buying this or adding that to fix it when, more often than not, the problem takes care of itself. Remember that everything in there depends on you for life. Fish size is important, not only the size they are, but the size they will become.

Your tank is going to amaze you. Enjoy it for everything it does, from the diatom bloom to the first new polyp. Don't try to rush natural art.
 
Here is a good thread with lots of info for beginners http://www.reefcentral.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1031074 you can bounce around between the different topics like chapters in a book.

I assume you mean gfo (granular ferric oxide) reactor.

You may want to run some granular activated carbon in case your leather emitted toxins as a defense to the large water change.

All the tangs except the yellow need to go back to the store.

Are you acclimating the new corals to your lights? A pic of your tank would probably help us see if they are well placed. I don't have that light, but it is not necessary to run lights 24/7.

It's usually better to focus on one class of coral in the beginning. As you are learning, it is difficult to meet the needs of different type in a single tank. I'd say if the coral that prefer clean water and lots of light are working for you, go with it and buy more of them.

These are really common mistakes. Everybody starts someplace and you'll get better with experience. Welcome to the hobby, and good luck!
 
Mikey, please tell us you are still around. Some of the comments may have sounded a bit harsh (mine included). But we really are just trying to help.
 
Mikey, please tell us you are still around. Some of the comments may have sounded a bit harsh (mine included). But we really are just trying to help.

yikes i guess i/ we did scare him away

Sadly I think you're both right.

Last Activity: 05/22/2016 02:28 PM


Hopefully he comes back and sees that everyone here is only wanting to help him succeed with his tank. It would be good to know where he lives as maybe someone lives close to him and can come help him to learn.
 
Back
Top