Newbie Peppermint Shrimp Rant

Eug40

Member
I noticed a couple of aptasia on one of my zoa frags and noticed a couple more tiny ones on my sand bed, hardly an outbreak, but wanted to nip it in the bud early. Seems like the consensus was the Peppermint shrimp was highly effective in this regard. I picked up a couple rather than one suggested to me by my LFS, and after a few hours of observing their funny behavior under my rocks, thought they would make a nice addition to my tank. First couple of days, they just hung upside down under the rocks. Next day, I noticed one on the affected frag and also noticed the tiny couple of aptasia in the sand bed were gone as well. Yay!
Day 4 I noticed them hanging out on a bare piece of rock where all my brittle stars have their arms hanging out. Noticing the lack of arms, I quickly researched if they preyed on brittles, and some people attested they did. This kind of bothered me as I grown to like all those arms sticking out but I wasnt proof positive that they were eating them(maybe they just scared the arms back in the rock crevices. However on day 5, I woke up to them perched on my favorite frag (and only) acan. Looking at the acan, you could see the severe damage to the heads. Almost like the rings that give it the great color were scraped clean. I immediately researched this as well and was met with an onslaught of horror stories of Peppermints eating acans. After doing a little more research, I noticed them picking at my Hammer as well!. They had to go right away...
Now came the horror show that was catching them. This was the worst and most frustrating part of the whole experience. Long post already, but to summarize, it took me all day to net them. Knocked over a bunch of my corals countless times, spread sand everywhere, rearranged my rockwork, water everywhere, fish ****ed.. coral retreated.. I got lucky with one relatively quickly, but the last one was a nightmare. I tried the bottle trap multiple times, and on every instance all I got were happy Nassarius. Didnt want to risk trapping overnight and have more damage done to the corals, so I was determined to get it done today.

I am sure I could have captured them better, but as a new reefer, this is my first experience taking things out as opposed to putting in. I feel like posting this in this forum as a precautionary tale. The difficulty in catching them and the bulldozing of my new tank had me seeing red, so I am venting at my keyboard now with this long winded post. I just don't know what to do next time the Aptasia comes.. Hoping there's another natural course of action.
 
PS After a couple of nicks from the rocks , I hope I dont have that paly poison Ive been reading about.
 
I noticed a couple of aptasia on one of my zoa frags and noticed a couple more tiny ones on my sand bed, hardly an outbreak, but wanted to nip it in the bud early. Seems like the consensus was the Peppermint shrimp was highly effective in this regard. I picked up a couple rather than one suggested to me by my LFS, and after a few hours of observing their funny behavior under my rocks, thought they would make a nice addition to my tank. First couple of days, they just hung upside down under the rocks. Next day, I noticed one on the affected frag and also noticed the tiny couple of aptasia in the sand bed were gone as well. Yay!
Day 4 I noticed them hanging out on a bare piece of rock where all my brittle stars have their arms hanging out. Noticing the lack of arms, I quickly researched if they preyed on brittles, and some people attested they did. This kind of bothered me as I grown to like all those arms sticking out but I wasnt proof positive that they were eating them(maybe they just scared the arms back in the rock crevices. However on day 5, I woke up to them perched on my favorite frag (and only) acan. Looking at the acan, you could see the severe damage to the heads. Almost like the rings that give it the great color were scraped clean. I immediately researched this as well and was met with an onslaught of horror stories of Peppermints eating acans. After doing a little more research, I noticed them picking at my Hammer as well!. They had to go right away...
Now came the horror show that was catching them. This was the worst and most frustrating part of the whole experience. Long post already, but to summarize, it took me all day to net them. Knocked over a bunch of my corals countless times, spread sand everywhere, rearranged my rockwork, water everywhere, fish ****ed.. coral retreated.. I got lucky with one relatively quickly, but the last one was a nightmare. I tried the bottle trap multiple times, and on every instance all I got were happy Nassarius. Didnt want to risk trapping overnight and have more damage done to the corals, so I was determined to get it done today.

I am sure I could have captured them better, but as a new reefer, this is my first experience taking things out as opposed to putting in. I feel like posting this in this forum as a precautionary tale. The difficulty in catching them and the bulldozing of my new tank had me seeing red, so I am venting at my keyboard now with this long winded post. I just don't know what to do next time the Aptasia comes.. Hoping there's another natural course of action.

Snowflake eel. Problem solved.... :lmao:
 
Panic is never good. Patience is a virtue. Corals grow back. I have a feeling if you'd sat down and thought about it for a while, you could have figured out a way to catch those shrimp without tearing up your tank. You didn't even give the traps a chance to work overnight, and you probably did more damage yourself than the shrimp could have done in a week. Next time maybe ask for advice BEFORE you bulldoze the tank. Don't mean to be harsh, but you're going to go through a lot of ups a downs in this hobby, and if you go into panic mode every time something goes wrong, you're never going to enjoy it. Just remember, you're smarter than a shrimp.

Sent from my RS988 using Tapatalk
 
New to the hobby as well and don't know much about corals yet but I did watch a video on youtube about killing it with a sarenge and lemon juice not sure the link but was a girl that's famous for her cow fish named cheese lol hope this helps.
 
If you fed them they wouldn’t care to eat coral. I have a breeding colony of peppermints and not once have they even looked at a coral. I’m guessing you have a smallish tank so they are starving. Good news is they will obviously eat anything. Give them a puff of mysis once a week and you’ll be fine. I’m thinking this forum instills too much panic in new impatient reefers. Don’t believe all you hear. 99% of the horror stories come from those who have no idea what they are doing.
 
If you fed them they wouldn't care to eat coral. I have a breeding colony of peppermints and not once have they even looked at a coral. I'm guessing you have a smallish tank so they are starving. Good news is they will obviously eat anything. Give them a puff of mysis once a week and you'll be fine. I'm thinking this forum instills too much panic in new impatient reefers. Don't believe all you hear. 99% of the horror stories come from those who have no idea what they are doing.

Remember this was only a few days of having the shrimp, as opposed to weeks where the case could be made that they were being starved. An in that time they ate multiple pellets off the ground as well as partook in mysis feeding. I saw with my own eyes BOTH of them carving up my acan. I would blast them off, go right back and repeat. Then the hammer. I actually appreciate the stories that people post, serves as guidance as to if other people are experiencing similar things. Dunno, don't see what patience or saavy has to do in this case, when something you introduce is immediately destroying whats in the tank. Just sharing my experience.
 
New to the hobby as well and don't know much about corals yet but I did watch a video on youtube about killing it with a sarenge and lemon juice not sure the link but was a girl that's famous for her cow fish named cheese lol hope this helps.

lol, I'll look it up. As infuriating as they were, I didn't want to kill them, they're just doing what they do. Eating and avoiding capture. I have them in a separate compartment awaiting transport back to the LFS in a few hours.
 
New to the hobby as well and don't know much about corals yet but I did watch a video on youtube about killing it with a sarenge and lemon juice not sure the link but was a girl that's famous for her cow fish named cheese lol hope this helps.

ohhh lemon juice. hahaha got it now. Found her, she's hilarious.
 
Most things (even humans) will go after foods they normally wouldn't at certain times due to necessity to stay alive..
There are also multiple types of Peppermint Shrimp too.. Not all eat the same meals..

You likely just had a bad experience.. It happens on occasion.. In general we all don't have that same experience with them and they usually cause little to no damage..
Sometimes people also think they are going after the coral buy are just eating stuff living around the coral.. (not saying thats what happened here and damage was likely visible)
 
Are you sure you had peppermint shrimp? There are a couple species sold as "peppermint shrimp" that are not. For example, the camel shrimp which is not reef safe.
 
Back
Top