Pastor gets a year for selling baby sharks from bay

racrumrine

New member
I wonder if this is how 6th Avenue was getting their sharks...
______________________

Pastor gets a year for selling baby sharks from bay
- Henry K. Lee, Chronicle Staff Writer
Tuesday, January 23, 2007


(01-23) 15:44 PST SAN LEANDRO -- A San Leandro pastor has been sentenced to a year and a day in prison for illegally catching thousands of undersized California leopard sharks in San Francisco Bay and selling them to aquarium dealers, authorities said today.

Kevin Thompson, 49, pastor at the Bay Area Family Church and the co-owner of at least one fishing boat, was also ordered Monday to pay $100,000 in restitution for his role in a conspiracy in which five others have been implicated, according to federal prosecutors.

He is scheduled to surrender March 19 to begin serving his sentence on one count of conspiracy.

An indictment handed down by a federal grand jury last year accused the defendants of conspiring to harvest young sharks from the bay and sell them to distributors in the pet trade. About 465 of the sharks were sold to companies in Miami, Chicago, Houston, Romulus, Mich., Milford, Conn., the Netherlands and the United Kingdom, prosecutors said.

The sharks are found in coastal waters from Baja California to Oregon. The species is protected by a 1994 state law that prohibits commercial catches of juvenile leopard sharks shorter than 36 inches, in order to let them live in the wild long enough to reproduce and maintain healthy stocks. Selling wildlife with the knowledge that it was captured illegally is a federal crime.

The John G. Shedd Aquarium in Chicago and the Monterey Bay Aquarium assisted authorities in the two-year investigation and helped transport and tend to 19 baby leopard sharks that had been confiscated.

Nine of those sharks were returned to the wild in Monterey Bay in summer 2004. Three remain on exhibit at the Monterey Bay Aquarium; seven died.

The other defendants, all of whom have pleaded guilty in the case, are Vincent Ng, 44, of Oakland, owner of Amazon Aquarium in Alameda; Ira Gass, 54, a marine aquarium dealer from Azusa (Los Angeles County); John Newberry, 35, of Hayward, a church member and employee at Pan Ocean Aquarium; Hiroshi Ishikawa, 37, of San Leandro, a church member and a fisherman; and Sion Lim, 40, of San Leandro, owner of Bayside Aquatics in Oakland.

Ishikawa was sentenced in October to three years of probation and was ordered to pay $40,000 in restitution. Lim was sentenced in June to a year of probation and was ordered to pay $20,000 in restitution.

U.S. District Judge Claudia Wilken in Oakland is set to sentence Newberry on Feb. 2, Gass on Feb. 5 and Ng on Feb. 9.

E-mail Henry K. Lee at hlee@sfchronicle.com.
 
Re: Pastor gets a year for selling baby sharks from bay

The sharks are found in coastal waters from Baja California to Oregon. The species is protected by a 1994 state law that prohibits commercial catches of juvenile leopard sharks shorter than 36 inches, in order to let them live in the wild long enough to reproduce and maintain healthy stocks. Selling wildlife with the knowledge that it was captured illegally is a federal crime.

The article leaves out the tidbit that IIRC, if you are fishing for fun for leopard sharks and you catch a gravid female you are allowed to gut it and let the 30+ pups die. Drive around Bay Farm over the weekend and you'll see a dozen examples a day during the season.
 
Re: Re: Pastor gets a year for selling baby sharks from bay

Re: Re: Pastor gets a year for selling baby sharks from bay

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=9059518#post9059518 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Thales
if you are fishing for fun for leopard sharks and you catch a gravid female you are allowed to gut it and let the 30+ pups die.
Sad but so true.:(
 
It is STUPID people like this that give this industry a bad reputation!

Notice how the media jumps all over stories like this but does two sentence articles on how individuals and groups/companies are making a difference?!

These people knew exactly what they were doing, they will never have my respect and I hope that they get what is coming to them.

Yes I know that the law is backward and screwy but it is still the law, and yes I dont agree with some of the regulations thats why we need to have actual scientists help make the laws not professional bureaucrats.

Decending from the soap box,

tyler
 
two words : freshwater rays :D

I've seen them in the pat in stores, along with Leopard sharks, caularpa, hygrophylia, etc, etc.

Simply being caught with something doesn't equate to knowingly breaking the law ;)
 
How about 465 somethings?

"An indictment handed down by a federal grand jury last year accused the defendants of conspiring to harvest young sharks from the bay and sell them to distributors in the pet trade. About 465 of the sharks were sold to companies in Miami, Chicago, Houston, Romulus, Mich., Milford, Conn., the Netherlands and the United Kingdom, prosecutors said. "
 
I'm sure there's more than 465 fuges filled with caulerpa in CA.

The media is pretty one-sided. The leopards that were caught and sold were juveniles that had been collected when gravid females (legal size) were caught and the pups were saved. As Rich said, apparently you'll get in trouble for saving the pups rather than letting them die. I know for a fact that not everybody invloved knew this.

Best not to judge people unless you know the entirety of both sides.
 
So are you saying that the Pastor is going to prison for running a leopard shark rescue mission?

You must have a lot more info about the workings of their ministry, I can't read that much into the article.

If they weren't catching the sharks with their boats, they probably wouldn't have to rescue them. Perhaps the government should make rules that you can only take males (like with crabs).

Best of luck,

Roy

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=9064889#post9064889 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by ViPeR_930
I'm sure there's more than 465 fuges filled with caulerpa in CA.

The media is pretty one-sided. The leopards that were caught and sold were juveniles that had been collected when gravid females (legal size) were caught and the pups were saved. As Rich said, apparently you'll get in trouble for saving the pups rather than letting them die. I know for a fact that not everybody invloved knew this.

Best not to judge people unless you know the entirety of both sides.
 
I see the Bay Area Family Church is a Rev. Sun Myung Moon institution.
I'm not sure the refugium analogy is accurate since caulerpa was recently made illegal and many of those sumps were filled prior or from legally acquired starts.
 
Personally, I have a different perception of "saving". Even though the leopard shark pups may have died otherwise, I don't consider a person selling leopard shark pups to aquarium stores (where they're likely to end up in Joe schmo's 20 gallon fish tank) to pad his own pockets as particularly heroic.
 
IIRC caulerpa was made illegal in 2001. Even though people may have had it before 2001, they aren't exempt from the law now. I'm sure 5 years is long enough to get rid of a tank of caulerpa.
I know of a few LFS in the Bay Area selling illegal stock, and not just caulerpa.

I agree it's not a heroic act either, but as far as selling to or from fish stores it's just like with any other fish/coral/invert/etc. How much do you guys suppose the leopard sharks were being sold for retail? Throw me a figure.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=9064889#post9064889 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by ViPeR_930
The leopards that were caught and sold were juveniles that had been collected when gravid females (legal size) were caught and the pups were saved.

From what I know of that 'pastor', that gets harder to swallow. If it was his boat fishing for the sharks and then selling the pups the line between commercial and sport get considerably murky.

[quopte] As Rich said, apparently you'll get in trouble for saving the pups rather than letting them die. [/quote]

Absolutely. Legal is legal, illegal is illegal. The only thing I point out in mentioning the stupidity of the current law is in regards to mitigation of the punishment.
 
"Absolutely. Legal is legal, illegal is illegal. The only thing I point out in mentioning the stupidity of the current law is in regards to mitigation of the punishment."

Rich I agree with you! But these people had to know what they were doing especially the people in the "industry". When was the last time that you saw Leopard Shark and ANY wholesale list? Sion, John and Vince knew better. They thought that they could make a buck under the radar.

Yes there are alot of store selling illegal products and not just Caulerpa. I can think of at least two stores in the the South Bay that DO NOT sell illegal products. But I can see what the other stores logic might be ...... if there is a demand and if F&G is not going to inspect ...... might as well.

Tyler
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=9065936#post9065936 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Thales
Absolutely. Legal is legal, illegal is illegal. The only thing I point out in mentioning the stupidity of the current law is in regards to mitigation of the punishment.
I totally agree with you. I was just pointing out that the media doesn't get all the facts down. There's always two sides to every story.

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=9066157#post9066157 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by MorandiWine
But these people had to know what they were doing especially the people in the "industry". When was the last time that you saw Leopard Shark and ANY wholesale list? Sion, John and Vince knew better. They thought that they could make a buck under the radar.
I wouldn't assume so much, Tyler.
 
Back
Top