Pastor gets a year for selling baby sharks from bay

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=9183954#post9183954 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by bookfish
I think Mikes point is correct. If they, as professionals in the MO industry, didn't know this was illegal, it was their responsibility to find out BEFORE beginning to trade in that species. The fact that there are silly laws doesn't change this. I personally find it hard to believe that everyone involved didn't know this was illegal. I'd be interested to know what they were putting on the export docs. If they identified the shipment as containing CA leopard sharks, wouldn't USF&G have stopped the shipment? If they listed the sharks as a different species, doesn't that imply they knew this was illegal?

They all pleaded guilty from the beginning.
 
Moon church settles poach case

Moon church settles poach case

Here's an update. This morning, I also heard the last few minutes of a audio piece that was presented on NPR (National Public Radio). I didn't get to hear the whole thing. They will probably repeat it later today. Apparantly, there was a big news conference at the Monterey Bay Aquarium about this yesterday.

According to the Feds, this was a well organized poaching operation during the sharks breeding season and it took them awhile to catch them.

Best of luck,

Roy
____________________________
BAY AREA
Moon church settles poach case
Members sold sharks taken from bay to aquarium dealers
John Coté, Chronicle Staff Writer

Tuesday, February 13, 2007

Printable Version Email This Article
The Rev. Sun Myung Moon's church avoided prosecution in a shark-poaching case after it agreed to pay $500,000 to help restore California leopard shark habitat in San Francisco Bay, federal prosecutors said Monday.

Moon's organization, the Holy Spirit Association for Unification of World Christianity, agreed to contribute to the new $1.5 million habitat, U.S. Attorney Kevin Ryan said a statement.

Under the deal, prosecutors agreed not to bring charges of conspiracy or aiding and abetting against Moon's organization, said Anthony Chavez, a spokesman for the U.S. attorney's office.

Federal prosecutors had accused a pastor with Moon's church, the Rev. Kevin Thompson of San Leandro, of heading a poaching ring that fished thousands of undersize leopard sharks from the bay and sold them to aquarium dealers. The president of the church, the Rev. Michael Jenkins, said officials had been unaware of Thompson's activities.

Thompson's church, Bay Area Family Church, is part of the organization founded by Moon, the Korean evangelist and self-proclaimed messiah.

Thompson led Bay Area Family Church members in a poaching operation for more than 10 years, authorities said. The group used church vessels to illegally capture leopard sharks, which were then sold to companies in Miami; Chicago; Houston; Romulus, Mich.; Milford, Conn.; the Netherlands; and the United Kingdom, prosecutors said.

The sharks, considered exotic and valued by some collectors, were sold for between $9 and $75 apiece, authorities said.

Thompson and five other men have pleaded guilty in the case. Thompson was sentenced Jan. 22 to one year and one day in prison. He is scheduled to begin serving his sentence March 19. He has resigned from the church, Jenkins said.

"The church was not aware that Rev. Thompson was engaged in illegal activity," Jenkins said. "The church did not direct and does not condone such conduct."

In addition to the church's $500,000 contribution, the six men will pay a combined $410,000 in restitution, which will go to the habitat fund, prosecutors said.

The California Coastal Conservancy will provide $300,000 for the new habitat. The David and Lucile Packard Foundation, the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation and the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation will contribute a total of $300,000 as well, prosecutors said.

E-mail John Coté at jcote@sfchronicle.com.

This article appeared on page B - 5 of the San Francisco Chronicle
 
Church to pay into wildlife fund over shark poaching convictions

Church to pay into wildlife fund over shark poaching convictions

This is a much better article on what they were doing

___________________________________
Church to pay into wildlife fund over shark poaching convictions
By MARCUS WOHLSEN, Associated Press Writer

Monday, February 12, 2007

Printable Version Email This Article
(02-12) 16:13 PST San Francisco (AP) --


The church founded by the Rev. Sun Myung Moon will pay $500,000 to restore damaged habitat â€" and avoid prosecution â€" in a case of a pastor who poached hundreds of baby sharks from San Francisco Bay, federal prosecutors said Monday.


The Unification Church's payment â€" part of a "non-prosecution agreement" with the U.S. Attorney's Office in San Francisco â€" will go toward a $1.5 million fund to undo the environmental damage inflicted by the pastor's bizarre scheme.


Kevin Thompson, 48, pastor of the Bay Area Family Church in San Leandro, pleaded guilty in January to enlisting church members in an 11-year operation to illegally catch and sell the undersized leopard sharks to pet stores.


He was sentenced to one year and one day in prison and ordered to pay $100,000, which will also go toward the wildlife restoration fund.


Four men in the aquarium industry and a commercial fisherman also pleaded guilty to aiding the poaching effort and will pay a combined $310,000 into the fund. An additional $600,000 will be provided by the state and private foundations.


At least 465 leopard sharks too small to catch â€" and allegedly thousands more â€" were sold to pet distributors throughout the United States, the Netherlands and the United Kingdom.


"Part of what we do in the church is use boats for training with young people," Thompson told authorities in an interview that appears in court documents. "That's part of our faith. That's what Reverend Moon taught us."


The ocean plays an important role in Moon's teaching. He founded his Ocean Church in the 1980s based on the belief that fishing is a holy activity that reflects God's will for humans to have dominion over the sea.


In a recording of a 2003 sermon, Thompson unabashedly told his congregation just how far he believed that dominion extended, boasting that members of what he called the "Ocean Church" had spent more than a decade catching and selling baby leopard sharks to pet stores.


"We want the smaller the better," Thompson said.


Thompson bragged that a fellow church member had one day discovered a leopard shark pupping ground in mud flats along the bay and had returned with more than 100 baby sharks. He said pet stores would pay $20 per shark and sell them for home aquariums for $75 each.


Moon himself became excited when he learned about the shark-catching operation, Thompson claimed in the sermon.


"He told me, you know you need 20 boats out there fishing," Thompson said. "He had this big plan drawn out."


Rev. Moon "did not have any kind of personal knowledge or involvement with the details or the particulars" of Thompson's operation, said Rev. Phillip Schanker, a spokesman for the church. Any conversation that may have taken place would have been in the context of Thompson having a casual conversation with his 87-year-old spiritual leader about fishing, an activity they both enjoyed.


In a statement, Rev. Michael Jenkins, president of the Unification Church of America, said the church was not aware Thompson was engaged in illegal activity.


"The Church did not direct and does not condone such conduct," Jenkins said. The Unification Church was contributing money to the restoration fund "to make something positive of this unfortunate circumstance," Jenkins said.


Thompson has resigned from his position as pastor at the church, Jenkins said.


According to the federal indictment against Thompson and the other men, the Bay Area Family Church owned three boats, at least one of which Thompson told authorities was used for shark fishing.


The boats were stored "for years," Thompson said in interview transcripts, at a San Leandro distribution center for one of the largest sushi wholesalers in the U.S., True World Foods, Inc., a business founded by Unification Church members.


A message left with a manager at True World was not immediately returned.


California leopard sharks, which can take 13 years to reach maturity, live as long as 30 years and are protected under a state law that prohibits the commercial catching of specimens under 36 inches long. Prosecutors said federal wildlife agents seized sharks ranging from 8 1/2-inches to 17 1/2-inches in length.


The charges resulted from an investigation that followed the 2003 conviction of a pet distributor in Miami who was caught with more than a dozen leopard sharks from California, according to federal prosecutors.


Seven of the 19 baby leopard sharks confiscated during the two-year investigation died, the U.S. Attorney's office said. Three are on exhibit at the Monterey Bay Aquarium, and nine were returned to the wild in the summer of 2004.


The other five defendants who pleaded guilty are: John Newberry, 34, of Hayward; Ira Gass, 53, of Azusa; Hiroshi Ishikawa, 36, of San Leandro, Vincent Ng, 43, of Oakland; and Sion Lim, 39, of San Francisco.
 
From the Monterey Herald

From the Monterey Herald

I finally heard the whole radio spot on NPR at 7:44am. It ran for about 5 minutes.

They were intentially fishing at night to catch the sharks. The pastor said that the poaching was God's will. If you can't hear it today, you'll be able to listen to the archives starting tomorrow. http://www.npr.org/

Best of luck,

Roy
______________________
Fines aid leopard sharks
Poaching probes lead to restoring shrinking habitat
By KEVIN HOWE
Herald Staff Writer

VERN FISHER/The Herald
United States Attorney Kevin Ryan announces $1.5 million fund to restore diminishing leopard shark habitat at the Monterey Bay Aquarium on Monday. $910,000 will come from restitution received from poachers.A three-year investigation by authorities in four states and four countries over an extensive leopard shark poaching operation reaped more than $900,000 in restitution money that will be used to expand and protect the sharks' habitat.

Fines imposed on the pastor and members of a Unification Church in San Leandro will help pay for the habitat restoration, said federal officials. The Unification Church was founded by the Rev. Sun Myung Moon.

The case underscores the seriousness with which federal and state authorities regard wildlife laws, said U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service special agent Lisa Nichols at a news conference Monday at Monterey Bay Aquarium.

The media gathering was held to announce the results of the investigation into the poaching of undersized leopard sharks in the bay for sale as exotic aquarium fish to collectors.

They may be considered "trash fish" to some, but the leopard sharks that breed in San Francisco are protected under state and federal law.

The perpetrators identified by federal authorities included the pastor and two members of the San Leandro church, the owners of aquarium supply businesses in Oakland and Alameda and a buyer and seller in Azusa.

"We commonly see an attitude of indifference to wildlife law," Nichols said. "If people don't see it enforced, they ignore it."

The investigation started as four separate probes of Internet sales of the leopard sharks, she said, and coalesced into a single investigation.

In all, Nichols said, investigators believe 10,000 to 15,000 leopard sharks were illegally collected from San Francisco Bay.

"It's difficult to get public sympathy," she said, "when the animal is not warm, fuzzy and cute," but the sharks play an important part in "the balance of a system that was set up to balance itself."

The investigation began in Miami, Nichols said, when a pet trade distributor was caught with 18 undersized leopard sharks from California and was convicted. The Chicago and Los Angeles U.S. Attorney's offices became involved and their investigations led back to the San Francisco Bay Area, where the principal suppliers are located.

Several of those charged, she said, claimed not to know what the law was. "They have an obligation to know what the laws are, and most did know."

One immediate effect of the convictions, she said, has been driving the open Internet trade in leopard sharks and other protected species underground, and some traders are now explaining the law to customers on their sites.

U.S. Attorney Kevin Ryan said that the $910,000 paid as restitution by the church and the criminal defendants is part of a fund that will be used for rehabilitating and restoring marine wildlife habitat in San Francisco Bay.

The Holy Spirit Association for the Unification of World Christianity, which includes the Bay Area Family Church in San Leandro that was named as one of the participants in the poaching case, has agreed to pay $500,000 for the wildlife restoration partnership as part of a nonprosecution agreement, he said, and five individuals convicted in the case will pay $410,000.

The Rev. Michael Jenkins, president of the Unification Church of America, said Monday that the Church was not aware that Thompson was engaged in an illegal activity, did not direct and does not condone such conduct, and church policy explicitly prohibits the use of its assets in such activity.

Thompson, Jenkins said, has resigned from his position as pastor.

Another $300,000 from the California Coastal Conservancy and $300,000 through the combined contributions of the David and Lucile Packard Foundation, the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation, and the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation were designated for the same purpose Monday, for a total of $1.51 million.

Ryan called the dedication of the restitution funds for the shark habitat "a creative resolution" of the case.

Those convicted included Kevin Thompson, the pastor of the Bay Area Family Church; Ira Gass, 53, of Azusa; Vincent Ng, 43, of Oakland; John Newberry, 34, of Hayward; Hiroshi Ishikawa, 36, of San Leandro; and Sion Lim, 39, of San Francisco.

Thompson, Gass and Ng were each ordered to pay $100,000 in restitution; Newberry $50,000; Ishikawa $40,000; and Lim $20,000, Ryan said, and they also received jail and/or probation sentences.

The investigation included state and federal authorities, as well as investigators in the United Kingdom and the Netherlands, said Don Masters, special agent-in-charge of the Southwest Region of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Fisheries Service.

He noted that Monterey Bay Aquarium, along with Shedd Aquarium in Chicago and the Cabrillo Aquarium in San Pedro, assisted federal authorities by caring for 19 baby sharks seized by agents.

California leopard sharks were afforded extra protection by the state when a minimum size limit of 36 inches for any commercial take of the sharks was set by the state Fish and Game Code.

Habitat loss is a major threat to the sharks, said Amy Hutzel, bay program manager for the State Coastal Conservancy, who noted that 85 percent of San Francisco Bay's habitat has been lost due to development that began during the California Gold Rush.

"We now have the opportunity to double the amount of tidal marshes in the Bay" through the restoration program, she said.

The restoration, which will begin this spring, she said, will convert 40,000 acres of salt ponds to marshland for fish habitat.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Kevin Howe can be reached at 646-4416 or khowe@montereyherald.com.
 
Thanks Roy!

I think its lame that the moonies can throw money at the problem instead of being taken to court.
 
The scope of the poaching ring was unprecedented, said U.S. Attorney Maureen Bessette, who spearheaded the prosecution. The six men, including three aquarium-shop owners, captured thousands of baby leopard sharks to sell to collectors, often for as much as $240, said Lisa Nichols, an agent for the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.

From the Mercury News.

Thousands of sharks! What's the attraction of this specific animal to collectors? I guess it's a shark.
 
That Moon guy seems like a real piece of work, I agree with Rich about the financial bail out. I wonder is his church 5013c? Is that legal to have a non profit use its funds to bail someone out? Mr. mans domination of the sea will be on to some other shenanigans, just hope it's a non-native species (just don't tell him their NN).
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=9231252#post9231252 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by reefkeeper1
From the Mercury News.

Thousands of sharks! What's the attraction of this specific animal to collectors? I guess it's a shark.

How many of any animal is collected for the collectors in our hobby? :D Thousands is on the low end in the bigger picture of marine ornamentals.

240 seems high to me.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=9231352#post9231352 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by tuberider
That Moon guy seems like a real piece of work, I agree with Rich about the financial bail out. I wonder is his church 5013c? Is that legal to have a non profit use its funds to bail someone out? Mr. mans domination of the sea will be on to some other shenanigans, just hope it's a non-native species (just don't tell him their NN).

Yep they are not taxed. Its not a bail out, its a donation. :roll:
 
Why is it that they are not collected in Mexico and shipped up? I often see Garabaldi that have paperwork from Mexico, and from what I have been told, that is all above ground - why would it be any different with Leopards from Mexico? (not that I condone keeping either species, just curious why it is done with one and not the other)
This bust makes sense, I was randomly at a party and saw a 125 with two baby leopards in it and did a double take (I figured he had caught them himself)- I asked the guy who owned the house about them, he had no idea what kind they were, said he just bought them from some shop in SF, and "aren't they gnarly!". Argh.
 
6th Avenue used to regularly carry them. I was in there the other day. Didn't see them.

Sadly, they had a spotted ray and a Chambered Nautilus.

Best of luck,

Roy
 
Back
Top