Peppermint Shrimp Warning

SAT

Premium Member
You may notice a difference between the two small Pocillopora colonies in this picture...

picture.php


The white one on the left was added two weeks ago. It looked very much like the on the right on the first evening. It looked like this (minus a bit of the algae) the following morning. The one on the right was added one week ago, after I removed the peppermint shrimp. In one night my 8 peppermint shrimp pulled 98% of the polyps off the first colony. Yum yum!

Before I go any further, yes I do know the difference between peppermint and camel shrimp. I have seen both many times. These were shipped to me by a reputable firm that collects in Florida (and I'm pretty sure they know the difference too). I have had the shrimp for about 2 years, but this is the first I have added small vulnerable animals to the tank in that time.

No I did not have any Aiptasia. They did not learn to eat corals or anemones in my tank... they figured that out on their own. They leave my large flower anemones alone, presumably from a strong sense of self preservation.

The shrimp also attacked a small flower anemone and a small Ricordea that I added at the same time as the first Pocillopora. I was able to save both of those before permanent damage was done.

Thanks to Mike at my LFS (Aquarium Specialties & Research) for replacing the Pocillopora free of charge, and accepting the evil shrimp I gifted him, after hearing my sob story. He told me he would keep the shrimp isolated... but they may go into the octopus tank.

BTW, there are more polyps visible on the damaged colony now than there were a week ago. I am hopeful it will recover.

The shrimp added a lot of life to the tank and, strangely, I miss them.
 
You may notice a difference between the two small Pocillopora colonies in this picture...



picture.php




The white one on the left was added two weeks ago. It looked very much like the on the right on the first evening. It looked like this (minus a bit of the algae) the following morning. The one on the right was added one week ago, after I removed the peppermint shrimp. In one night my 8 peppermint shrimp pulled 98% of the polyps off the first colony. Yum yum!



Before I go any further, yes I do know the difference between peppermint and camel shrimp. I have seen both many times. These were shipped to me by a reputable firm that collects in Florida (and I'm pretty sure they know the difference too). I have had the shrimp for about 2 years, but this is the first I have added small vulnerable animals to the tank in that time.



No I did not have any Aiptasia. They did not learn to eat corals or anemones in my tank... they figured that out on their own. They leave my large flower anemones alone, presumably from a strong sense of self preservation.



The shrimp also attacked a small flower anemone and a small Ricordea that I added at the same time as the first Pocillopora. I was able to save both of those before permanent damage was done.



Thanks to Mike at my LFS (Aquarium Specialties & Research) for replacing the Pocillopora free of charge, and accepting the evil shrimp I gifted him, after hearing my sob story. He told me he would keep the shrimp isolated... but they may go into the octopus tank.



BTW, there are more polyps visible on the damaged colony now than there were a week ago. I am hopeful it will recover.



The shrimp added a lot of life to the tank and, strangely, I miss them.



How do you feed your shrimp?

Btw - picture does not show for me.


Pszemol
--
Maroon Clownfish, breeding pair, 4 Red BTAs.
 
How do you feed your shrimp?

Btw - picture does not show for me.

They scavenged excess fish food (mostly mysis shrimp). The mysis also fed the anemones.

There may be some trick to photos I'm not aware of... it shows for me even if I log out. Are you having trouble with other photos?
 
They scavenged excess fish food (mostly mysis shrimp). The mysis also fed the anemones.



There may be some trick to photos I'm not aware of... it shows for me even if I log out. Are you having trouble with other photos?



No, I do not see problems with other photos.

Not sure how big is your tank, but 8 peppermint shrimps require a lot of food in form of direct feeding. I would feed them more and maybe they will live your corals alone. Too late for that now, of course, but you apparently miss them so I know you buy more shrimps pretty soon :-) A reef tank without shrimps is not worth keeping, if you ask me ;-)


Pszemol
--
Maroon Clownfish, breeding pair, 4 Red BTAs.
 
I wouldnt worry about it too much, pretty soon that pocci will be huge and spawning all over your tank, and then you will wish you had that shrimp back
 
I wouldnt worry about it too much, pretty soon that pocci will be huge and spawning all over your tank, and then you will wish you had that shrimp back

+1...get rid of all poci before it's too late!
 
I only had only one in my 40g. I fed it every day. One day I brought home a couple of ricordea mushrooms. The next morning I saw that the yuma was a lot smaller than when I first got it. It actually looked like it had lost some of it's tissue. But I wrote it off as it just not being used to my lighting. Then that same night, I saw the peppermint shrimp having it for dinner. I quickly pulled it out and put it in my QT. I also had a cleaner shrimp that I suspected my 6 line wrasse ate while it was molting. Now I"m not sure if it was the 6 line or the peppermint.
 
I put 2 peppermints in my tank on Friday. Haven't seen them since.:hmm2:



Is it a large tank? What other animals you have? They tent to be shy and hide in the rocks for some time.

If you want to see them, throw a meaty morsel into the tank at night, long after lights are out and fish are sleeping. You will see your shrimps grazing on the morsels under the cover of the night.


Pszemol
--
Maroon Clownfish, breeding pair, 4 Red BTAs.
 
Prior posters are right about pep shrimp habits. I see mine on the rare occasion that I feed heavily. And usually one at a time. I'm not sure if they work collectively to scavenge food but I rarely see both at a time.

I too have had nothing but bad luck with pep shrimp. Anything with an attractive polyp texture gets hammered, regardless of how I feed. My only solution was to have a rock structure sufficiently large (12x15x18) wherein my shrimp would feel secure and never want to leave its bowels. So now they don't come out to the open environment where the corals are.
 
Is it a large tank? What other animals you have? They tent to be shy and hide in the rocks for some time.

If you want to see them, throw a meaty morsel into the tank at night, long after lights are out and fish are sleeping. You will see your shrimps grazing on the morsels under the cover of the night.


Pszemol
--
Maroon Clownfish, breeding pair, 4 Red BTAs.

It is a 90. Has a ton of places to hide, and only 2 other inhabitants besides CUC. "Fred" the blue spotted Jawfish, and "Wilma" the copper banded butterfly. Funny, I had a few aptasia so I bought Wilma thinking that would be the solution. It wasn't, so I bought the peppermints, it wasn't the solution either. Aptasia X is a sure thing...:thumbsup:
 
It is a 90. Has a ton of places to hide, and only 2 other inhabitants besides CUC. "Fred" the blue spotted Jawfish, and "Wilma" the copper banded butterfly. Funny, I had a few aptasia so I bought Wilma thinking that would be the solution. It wasn't, so I bought the peppermints, it wasn't the solution either. Aptasia X is a sure thing...:thumbsup:



Is your rockwork glued?

How many polyps of Aiptasia are we talking about?

If not glued and you have 2-3 polyps only, you could remove the piece affected and try to scrape what you can, squirt some vinegear in the area and glue/seal the rest of the crevice with putty/epoxy. Then rinse the rock with seawater and put it back to the tank.


Pszemol
--
Maroon Clownfish, breeding pair, 4 Red BTAs.
 
Back
Top