pitted stonefish

rayn

New member
DD has one on there and I am seriously considering it. I would place it in with my I. didactylus in a 40b. Thoughts?
 
Bingo I've been searching since lunch or whenever I got the email alert. Not much out there and it kinda makes me nervous.
 
Dang, I didn't get to see him. If anyone on here got it, I wanna see! :)

EDIT: Googled it... It's awesome looking... I still would like to see pictures of it in someone's tank though.
 
While Erosa does indeed belong to the family Synanceiidae (stonefishes), so do the stingfishes (Choridactylus and Inimicus). In fact, looking at the fish, it actually closely resembles C. multibarbus with a LARGE mouth and no dactyls. Sizewise, it's close to the Red Sea Stonefish (Synanceia nana) at 5" - 6" max.

The fish in question is a Western Pacific species, and has been photographed in the Lembeh Strait. Sure seems like a lot of really cool fish hang out there!

As far as where Erosa lies in the toxicity scheme of things, I suspect that it's at least as bad as the stingfish, maybe more (I sure wish I could find that reference on scorp toxicity!). I'd treat the fish pretty much the same way in terms of handling.

Fish like this showing up suddenly is the exact reason "scorp hunters" need to have a QT ready to go at "cualquier rato"...
 
My opinion on keeping them is based on it belonging to the family Synanceiidae. While there are plenty of experienced scorp keepers out there that could easily and safely keep this species, the potential for accidents and ignorance are too high for the risk level.

Like I already stated, just my opinion.

Gorgeous fish though....
 
I had it in my cart too, just couldn't quite pull the trigger on it. I really like info before I just buy and leap in, done that in the past and don't want to repeat. Hopefully something else pops up soon!
 
It was us BTW...should be here today and we have a tank up and running/ready to go.

Again, as far as collecting these fish, you almost always have to have a QT up and running for "just such an occasion". Of course, at 2", the QT will also be a "grow-out" tank for awhile (how do you think we ended up with 13 setups?).
 
I was thinking it might be a good addition to the "medium" lion/scorp tank, but we'll need to see how large its mouth is...looks pretty big from the pix I've seen.
 
I thought about getting one but it seems like there just a big, boring, camoflaged, venomous, meaner version of an angler is what it comes down too imo.
Just skip to the last 0:15 of the first vid lol

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Z9fbnjrpiM&feature=youtube_gdata_player

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gY2-fsASSxo&feature=youtube_gdata_player

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8phtoh2Wf2Q&feature=youtube_gdata_player

Pretty weird to actually see one swimming lol

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u5IChhNS3Iw&feature=youtube_gdata_player

Sorry if i went overboard on the vids hahah
 
Last edited:
I thought about getting one but it seems like there just a big, boring, camoflaged, venomous, meaner version of an angler is what it comes down too imo.
Just skip to the last 0:15 of the first vid lol

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Z9fbnjrpiM&feature=youtube_gdata_player

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gY2-fsASSxo&feature=youtube_gdata_player

Pretty weird to actually see one swimming lol

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u5IChhNS3Iw&feature=youtube_gdata_player

Not that it matters, but the person who owns those fish actually frequents this forum. Scorpaeniformes aren't for everybody, and are a lot more interesting and diverse than many give them credit for. Also, scorps are about as docile as fish come, they just get a bad rap for being able to defend themselves and because they're preds (like most other fish).

Then again, I hate clownfish...hate them...there's something for everyone in this hobby.
 
I didn't think the pitted and the one in the video were the same fish.

Docile! That is saying it lightly, they hardly move unless your talking lions.
 
Back
Top