pressure and its effect on corals in reef tanks

BlazinJack

New member
I was having a discussion with a friend about where corals were found in the ocean and he brought up the fact that the corals are not at nearly the pressure or depth in our tanks as they are in the ocean and wondered what effect that the lack of pressure has on their growth and health. I was speechless! has anyone ever done a study or thought about this aspect of reef keeping? Just thought id start a nice little discussion here!!:thumbsup:
 
Good topic!

Most of the corals we have in are tanks are dependent on light to survive.

Does anyone know the max depth of a light dependent coral could be found at?
 
Ok, so I had to go do some reading on the subject before trying to formulate an answer. Thank you, that doesn't happen very often. I didn't actually find much, or I would have posted it, but I don't think pressure has much to do with coral health. Growth may be altered on some of the species . I think water motion(Swell & Current), lighting(Variation & Quality), diet(availability & variety) and water quality & stability probably play a more important role in growth and health. Both in the wild and in captivity. After all you are in the first atmosphere while diving as soon as you are under the water until you hit 33 feet. So all of our aquariums are in that. I would be interested in comparing wild and captive deep water coral skeletal growth, but we are just getting to the point where we can acquire and keep those corals well enough to grow.

68Rustang-I did just read an article(I think in Coral magazine, still looking for it) that zooxanthellae was found in black coral that was growing at 300ft. I need to find it though.
 
Very observant of your friend! Lucky for us, we don't need to maintain the exact environment that most corals live in to be able to keep them successfully.

Pressure doesn't seem to be an issue for corals, as many of the animals that we keep are found in rather shallow water, typically the top 60' of the water column. That's where most of the light is. Also, since corals are sessile, they don't have swim bladders like fish do, so aren't as susceptible to pressure changes.

On the surface we are subjected to 1 Atmosphere (ATM) of pressure from 18K ft of air above us. For every 33ft you descend underwater, you increase pressure by 1 ATM. That means that most coral specimens are found from 1 - 2.5 ATM.

Given the success of many corals in fairly shallow reef tanks, it appears that pressure is not a requirement for survival. Add to that the fact that most coral species can be found at varying depths in the ocean, though many have a preferred range.

A better question might be, what effect does altitude have on keeping aquariums and their inhabitants? That is also directly related to pressure.

At sea level, disolved oxygen (DO) reaches 100% saturation in air at 8.6mg/l. Water holds less DO than air, saltwater holds less DO than freshwater and as altitude increases, DO decreases. DO also decreases as temperature rises.

The following is an example of DO and temp, salinity and altitude for 100% saturation:

25c (77F) 0ppt = 8.26 mg/l O2, 36ppt = 6.72 mg/l O2, 36ppt + 5400ft = 5.5 mg/l O2
30c (86F) 0ppt = 7.56 mg/l O2, 36ppt = 6.20 mg/l O2, 36ppt + 5400ft = 5.0 mg/l O2

0ppt = Freshwater 36ppt = Saltwater

Most fish will start to succumb to O2 starvation around 4 mg/l, though some will survive at lower levels. High activity fish such as tangs and anthias have a higher DO requirements.

This is why a loss of power at our altitude can result in the loss of many of our tank inhabitants. Falling temperatures actually benefit this situation, but the most common mistake new folks make is to allow the heaters to come back on when the power does.

Summer also presents a problem for us. Tanks that reach upwards of 90F are certain to experience problems due to low DO levels.

Heavily planted tanks, or tanks with lots of Cheato in their refugium also need to watch DO levels. When the lights go off, plants take up O2, just as the fish do. By running the refugium light cycle opposite from the tank light cycle, you eliminate the likelihood for low DO levels.

Dissolved nutrients also reduce the DO level of the water. So high nitrate and phosphate levels, while bad for your corals, also reduce the DO level of the tank.

With all of that having been said, how in the world do we manage to keep critters alive in our tanks way up here? We supersaturate the water through the use of skimmers, surface agitation and increased flow. Regardless, we can't replicate the DO found in natural seawater.

What can we do to help increase DO? Run your tanks at cooler temperatures. Your fish and corals will be quite happy at 76F. Many animals will do well at even lower temperatures; research your animals. If a fish only aquarium, consider reducing the salinity for heavily stocked tanks. This is NOT a solution for reef tanks.

Pressure is a concern..... but for us, it's actually the lack of pressure!
 
Ha! In the time it took me to research and write the above, two other folks chimed in.

Good points all!
 
Does anyone know the max depth of a light dependent coral could be found at?

Reports from USGS surveys in Florida have found photosynthetic coral reefs at 250ft. Reports out of Hawaii have found species of photosynthetic corals as deep as 540ft!!
 

Similar threads

Back
Top