lageek3000
New member
I have a oceanic 70 gal with a Quiet One 6000 (1500gph) hooked externally to my sump. It has plenty of flow but is loud. Is there an external pump that is quiet, or am I going to have to put the pump in the sump?
Quiet external pump
- Thread starter lageek3000
- Start date
jtarmitage
Active member
I like the Sequence Snapper, though it may be too much flow for your situation. Look at the Velocity pumps. Very quiet, though heat transfer is a concern.
For the Velocity pumps.... How much heat transfer is compared to a Blueline/Panworld or Iwaki....? Or even a drop in pump like an Ehiem?
Which would have less add of heat? Internal Ehiem, external panworld or the like there are so many, or like a snapper.
I spoke with Sequence, The Dart/Snapper are the same pump only different impeller. I'm told you can throttle back the dart/snapper that will in fact use less energy and prolong the life of the pump. Like a reostat (sp?) You are required to use 2 inch input and need to run the majority of your run with 1.5 inch then reduce down to 3/4. you can put a ball valve on the return to decrease the flow accordingly.
Which would have less add of heat? Internal Ehiem, external panworld or the like there are so many, or like a snapper.
I spoke with Sequence, The Dart/Snapper are the same pump only different impeller. I'm told you can throttle back the dart/snapper that will in fact use less energy and prolong the life of the pump. Like a reostat (sp?) You are required to use 2 inch input and need to run the majority of your run with 1.5 inch then reduce down to 3/4. you can put a ball valve on the return to decrease the flow accordingly.
jtarmitage
Active member
I have not owned a Velocity, but I have seen one in action, as well as read many threads on them. They run very hot, very hot to the touch. Others suggesting that those pumps are responible for a 1-3 deg temp increase, though I have no exp with that.
Any pump of comparable wattage will add more heat if it is internal over external. That is common sense, as the heat has to go somewhere. The sequence pumps have a fairly large fan, but as the whole pump, fan included is larger than the likes of the panworlds, it is surprising that they are so much quieter. They do require larger plumbing, and the reduced friction may be part of the reason for lower heat.
Any pump of comparable wattage will add more heat if it is internal over external. That is common sense, as the heat has to go somewhere. The sequence pumps have a fairly large fan, but as the whole pump, fan included is larger than the likes of the panworlds, it is surprising that they are so much quieter. They do require larger plumbing, and the reduced friction may be part of the reason for lower heat.
jtarmitage
Active member
Well, I guess it would be a valid concern depending on your system. Without a chiller, it could be a huge problem depending on where you live. The problem is that with a hot running pump, you must use even more electricity to try and correct this problem. I have a chiller, but it is for those rare days when really needed. I prefer to have a cooler running pump, and you can't forget to be sure the stand is ventilated as well. It does no good to have the pump fan dispursing the heat into a virtually sealed stand, that then just heats up the water anyhow! I have been so impressed with my first snapper, that now I use 3, and a wahoo for my skimmer. I use no powerheads and no other pumps. I used to run Mags, until I realized the difference.
jtarmitage
Active member
Don't get me wrong, Eheims are superb pumps. One of the best on the market, but without a fan, they will contribute more heat to the water, that's all. Not necessarily bad, it just is what it is, one of the best of the magnetic pumps that can be run internal or external.
Wolfpack, the Velocity pumps are water cooled. They are cooled by the water that they pump so obviously heat transfer is a concern. Alot of people figure the wattage of a pump equates to the heat transfered. True to some degree but a water cooled pump is going to transfer more heat than most fan cooled pumps with equal power requirment. For fan cooled, one pump drawing 100 watts isn't necessarily going to transfer the same heat as any other 100 watt fan cooled pump. The Pan World/ Blueline / Coralife pumps run pretty cool. In fact, both of mine are just waqrm to the touch. The skimmer pump is just luke warm. The equivalent wattage Little Giant pumps for example run much hotter than the Pan Worlds and transfer more heat. Long way to go to say that wattage isnt the only indicator of heat transfer.
jtarmitage
Active member
Well put DarG. It makes you wonder what the real differences in the pumps causes that much of a heat issue!
Got it... But my Iwaki 40RLT. If I disconnect it for 2 or 3 days the temp with drop AT least 3 degrees. Last year sometime I have some sick fish that I was treating the tank for about a week. If I recall after the weeks end the tank was about 4 degrees less without the Iwaki running. I cannot find the watts for this pump, but I think it is around 170'ish. No doubt the iwaki so far has been bullet proof.... But I would love to know how much heat difference would be between the two pumps. I would like to have the benefit of a quiet pump. My tank is in my home office, so the iwaki hummmm is a little annoying.
Ewan
Premium Member
If it's quiet, it's going to transfer heat to the water. It's as easy as that. Pumps that don't make noise rely on the liquid being pumped to transfer heat. Otherwise, they're fan cooled.
That being said, eheims transfer very little heat to the water when run externally, IME.
Some of the smaller panworlds run without a fan. I have a panworld 40PX as a return that flows through my chiller. It's quiet, but the casing is HOT to the touch. I have a panworld 50PXX that runs my closed loop- it's fan cooled, and louder than any pump I've ever owned.
What's the application? You may need to trade off some heat for some silence...
-E.
That being said, eheims transfer very little heat to the water when run externally, IME.
Some of the smaller panworlds run without a fan. I have a panworld 40PX as a return that flows through my chiller. It's quiet, but the casing is HOT to the touch. I have a panworld 50PXX that runs my closed loop- it's fan cooled, and louder than any pump I've ever owned.
What's the application? You may need to trade off some heat for some silence...
-E.
jtarmitage
Active member
Sorry to disagree Ewan, but the sequence pumps are very quiet and much cooler than most other pumps I've seen. I think that the fan used is much larger than most, so it does not need to spin at the higher speeds of others fans, which would then be noisier. The sequence pumpheads and fans are noticeably larger than those of Iwaki's, panworlds, or the like. I assume that if the Eheims don't transfer much heat if run externally, then they must have better insulation between the pump and the impeller.
lageek3000
New member
Did velocity go out of business?
I have a Pan World 150PS and a Blueline 4oHD which is a Pan World equivalent. Both Pressure rated. The 55HD is around 1100 GPH (170 watts) and the 40HD 790 GPH (120 watts). Both are warm to the touch, not hot. The 55HD is warmer of the two but you could place your hand on it and leave it there indefinitely and not come close to burning it. The 40HD is just luke warm. Compare these to equivalent Little Giants for example and they are much quieter and run much cooler. My Chiller ran nearly 20% shorter cycle just by replacing those Little Giant pumps with the Pan Worlds. The Wattage was comparable between the two pumps.
Ewan, that Pan World 50 Pxx is non-pressure rated equivalent of the 150 PS which I own. It draws less power, by almost half I think, than my pressure rated version. Maybe there is a problem with yours? Or maybe it is running hotter and louder than it should because it is running more of a pressure situation than it is rated for? I don't know but at 170 watts, the 150 PS is drawing more power for the same flow rate as your 50 PXX (at 0 head) and mine runs warm, not hot, and is not loud at all. It's dead silent compared to a little giant pump for example. It's not silent but it isnt what anyone would call "loud" either.
Ewan, that Pan World 50 Pxx is non-pressure rated equivalent of the 150 PS which I own. It draws less power, by almost half I think, than my pressure rated version. Maybe there is a problem with yours? Or maybe it is running hotter and louder than it should because it is running more of a pressure situation than it is rated for? I don't know but at 170 watts, the 150 PS is drawing more power for the same flow rate as your 50 PXX (at 0 head) and mine runs warm, not hot, and is not loud at all. It's dead silent compared to a little giant pump for example. It's not silent but it isnt what anyone would call "loud" either.
One of my local shops has BlueLine/PW pumps on many of his tanks. There is so much noise in the shop it is hard to get a good guage on the quietness of those pumps. I hear alot of folks say they run cooler and quieter than an Iwaki. I have been a little reserved about spending the money to try them. I would like to have silent or as close as possible. My equipment is all in my stand below my tank in my home office. So I would like to reduce all the hummmmm as possible. I know my Iwaki is what I would consider pretty loud. That is my reasoning to find other options.
Similar threads
