Recent battle with Ich... And my course of action going forward.

plowro8

In Memoriam
About two months ago I added a flame angel and purple firefish to my tank. The tank was already stocked with a hi-fin goby, randall's shrimp goby, azure damsel, six line wrasse and maroon clown. Right after I added the flame to the tank, I noticed some white spots on him. He carried the spots for a few weeks (sometimes they would be less prevalent, but always came back), but eventually he lost his battle. Shortly after, the damsel succumbed to the same thing. About the time I lost the damsel, the maroon clown became very ill and looked about as bad as I've seen a fish look, but he kept eating, and within about a week or so he is completely back to normal. All the while, none of the other fish ever showed any signs of Ich.

I guess my main question is, can I ever introduce new fish to this tank again without removing the existing fish and treating them, then going fallow with the DT? Have the fish in the DT developed a resistance/immunity to the parasites in the tank? And knowing that the parasites need a host, but none of the fish showing any ill effects now, what are the parasites feeding on? When fish develop a resistance to Ich, will the parasite eventually die off, or is it always going to be there?
 
Removing all fish for treatment and leaving the tank fallow for 10-12 weeks is the only way to rid the tank of crypto. Fish can carry the parasite at a sub-clinical level without showing signs. Highly recommend that you read the stickies at the top of this forum to familiarize yourself with the cryptocaryon life cycle and how to treat for it. The link below also is a great primer on the organism:

http://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/fa164
 
So the fish in the tank now... Could they possibly live a long and healthy life without ever showing signs of Ich again?... now that they have apparently built a resistance? Or is that just naïve and wishful thinking?
 
Fish can develop temporary immunity, but the odds are against you long term. It just takes a stressful event like a power outage to upset the balance.
 
Temporary immunity seems to last six months. But the real issue is that ich does not have to be visible to be present and Ich in the kills is a problem. The life cycle of the parasite is such that infestation in closed tanks can be exponential over time.
 
Back
Top