Recommend Me A Powerhead

[MrHyde]

As far as that MP10 goes, what if the same results can be achieved for half or maybe one third of the price? Hmm... Definitely something to think about.

 

[RedStangGA]

As far as that MP10 goes, what if the same results can be achieved for half or maybe one third of the price? Hmm... Definitely something to think about.

Price shouldn't be the only consideration. Quality, durability, level of required maintenance, heat added to aquarium, and even aesthetics should all be considered.

I'm leery of Jebao's given that I've had 2 power heads die in less than a year and a similar brand return pump die after two.

Some people treat their equipment as disposable. If it breaks, no big deal, just replace it. Others do their best to keep consistent performance by having equipment that holds up and lasts. Can Jebao's last for years? Of course. But they're less likely to than a Vortech, Tunze, or similar pump.

When I started I had a Koralia nano in my 29gal biocube. When it went bad I replaced it with a Vortech and the avg temp of my tank dropped 1 full degree plus it took up less space in the tank.

Yes, it can be done cheaper than an MP10 but, like I said, price isn't always everything. If he can afford an MP10 then I'd suggest he buy one and be happy with it for years. If he can't, then absolutely look at less expensive alternatives.

 

[Nick30G]

I think im going to go with the Maxspect Gyre XF130 after some comparison and thought.

 

[MrHyde]

Price shouldn't be the only consideration. Quality, durability, level of required maintenance, heat added to aquarium, and even aesthetics should all be considered.

I'm leery of Jebao's given that I've had 2 power heads die in less than a year and a similar brand return pump die after two.

Some people treat their equipment as disposable. If it breaks, no big deal, just replace it. Others do their best to keep consistent performance by having equipment that holds up and lasts. Can Jebao's last for years? Of course. But they're less likely to than a Vortech, Tunze, or similar pump.

When I started I had a Koralia nano in my 29gal biocube. When it went bad I replaced it with a Vortech and the avg temp of my tank dropped 1 full degree plus it took up less space in the tank.

Yes, it can be done cheaper than an MP10 but, like I said, price isn't always everything. If he can afford an MP10 then I'd suggest he buy one and be happy with it for years. If he can't, then absolutely look at less expensive alternatives.

Yeah, I guess I should have specified a certain pump, but then again which ones are the most problematic in terms of quality, durability, level of maintenance required etc? I know they all have their bad apples, but can you rattle off some names for me so I know which ones to look out for? I'd rather not spend a ton of money on a pump either.

 

[Reeferz412]

Hey you go, flat out best pump for 55$. Get two if you don't think it will do it. Not controllable but effective, efficient, and small.


http://www.bulkreefsupply.com/tunze-turbelle-nanostream-6025.html

I have had the same one for about 6 years and I am the second owner. +1 great pumps and customer service is top notch. I had the old mount break on me and Roger Vitko (on RC here as tunze rep) sent a very inexpensive replacement part right away. This and ecotech are the only companies I know that provide upgraded parts for older gen pumps.

 

[Reeferz412]

My list of recommended pumps:

Ecotech Mp10 (you would only need 1)
Tunze Nanostream (probably need 2)
Jebao SW4 or PP4 (probably get away with 1)

 

[RedStangGA]

Yeah, I guess I should have specified a certain pump, but then again which ones are the most problematic in terms of quality, durability, level of maintenance required etc? I know they all have their bad apples, but can you rattle off some names for me so I know which ones to look out for? I'd rather not spend a ton of money on a pump either.

Well, that part gets fun. I pretty much listed the brands I had a bad experience with. Though I will say I don't consider Hydor "cheap" but rather inexpensive.

Again, from my experience, the MP10's I had were rock solid. I cleaned them about once per year. For a return I've been running an Eheim 1262 for several years after my Speedwave(I think that was the brand) died. I did have issues with my MP40.

After throwing money away on cheap gear I've joined the "Buy once, cry once" philosophy. That doesn't mean you have to buy the most expensive top brand gear. But make sure that you research your purchase and that what you're buying comes from a reputable manufacturer/company. This is especially true of life supporting devices. If your skimmer dies, you can somewhat make up for that with water changes while you find a new one. If your return dies while you're on a long weekend vacation, you might be screwed. If your powerhead dies while on a long weekend, your corals might be gone.

I will admit this is more applicable the larger your system is. My biocube held about $100 worth of fish and maybe $200 of corals. And, in the club I was in at the time, most of the corals would have been replaced by free frags in a catastrophic event. But once you start getting to hundreds or thousands of dollars worth of fish and/or corals, it's worth paying the premium to get known quality equipment. Some people much those that buy Abyzz pumps because of their insane cost. If I get to the point of thousands of dollars worth of livestock, $1300 for a pump might seem a bargain!

So, what I personally stay away from:
Pretty much anything made in and sold by primarily Chinese manufacturers. That's not a hard and fast rule as some quality stuff is made in China. Jebao and the like are not quality.

What I personally tend to respect in general:
Ecotech
Kessil
Tunze
Fluval
Eheim
Abyzz(Rock it if you can afford it!)
Reef Octopus(Skimmers, not enough data on their pumps yet)
AI
Geisseman
ATI
Reef Breeders
Maxspect
Vertex
Sicce
Hydor(One of the better budget choices IMO)


Also keep in mind this is my personal opinion based off of my limited experience. I've had two tanks, and relatively small at that at 29 and 60 gallons, over a 7 year period. That's it. I don't have mountains of data to back up my opinion because, well, I don't need to lol! I know some people love their Jebao gear and more power to them. I've just chosen not to trust it based off of my personal experience. Also, some manufacturers may sell a light product that's good but a skimmer or pump that sucks.

There's a host of other manufactures that I've left off of both lists. Regardless, research whatever you're about to buy. Don't base the decision off of a few reviews. If it's a new manufacturer, you're much better off waiting and buying something that has a longer history. This is why you still see many long time reefers using Eheim, Tunze, and other tried and true equipment. Same reason many still use T5, MH, or a combo. It's what has worked reliably for them for years.

 

[JTL]

REd, do you think a Eheim 1262 would be adequate on 100g about 5' of head and a 1/2" bulkhead. It would go in a 50g sump and needs to provide flow to a refugium and a dual media reactor. I just saw one new for $144 which I thought was a pretty good deal.

 

[MrHyde]

Well, that part gets fun. I pretty much listed the brands I had a bad experience with. Though I will say I don't consider Hydor "cheap" but rather inexpensive.

Again, from my experience, the MP10's I had were rock solid. I cleaned them about once per year. For a return I've been running an Eheim 1262 for several years after my Speedwave(I think that was the brand) died. I did have issues with my MP40.

After throwing money away on cheap gear I've joined the "Buy once, cry once" philosophy. That doesn't mean you have to buy the most expensive top brand gear. But make sure that you research your purchase and that what you're buying comes from a reputable manufacturer/company. This is especially true of life supporting devices. If your skimmer dies, you can somewhat make up for that with water changes while you find a new one. If your return dies while you're on a long weekend vacation, you might be screwed. If your powerhead dies while on a long weekend, your corals might be gone.

I will admit this is more applicable the larger your system is. My biocube held about $100 worth of fish and maybe $200 of corals. And, in the club I was in at the time, most of the corals would have been replaced by free frags in a catastrophic event. But once you start getting to hundreds or thousands of dollars worth of fish and/or corals, it's worth paying the premium to get known quality equipment. Some people much those that buy Abyzz pumps because of their insane cost. If I get to the point of thousands of dollars worth of livestock, $1300 for a pump might seem a bargain!

So, what I personally stay away from:
Pretty much anything made in and sold by primarily Chinese manufacturers. That's not a hard and fast rule as some quality stuff is made in China. Jebao and the like are not quality.

What I personally tend to respect in general:
Ecotech
Kessil
Tunze
Fluval
Eheim
Abyzz(Rock it if you can afford it!)
Reef Octopus(Skimmers, not enough data on their pumps yet)
AI
Geisseman
ATI
Reef Breeders
Maxspect
Vertex
Sicce
Hydor(One of the better budget choices IMO)


Also keep in mind this is my personal opinion based off of my limited experience. I've had two tanks, and relatively small at that at 29 and 60 gallons, over a 7 year period. That's it. I don't have mountains of data to back up my opinion because, well, I don't need to lol! I know some people love their Jebao gear and more power to them. I've just chosen not to trust it based off of my personal experience. Also, some manufacturers may sell a light product that's good but a skimmer or pump that sucks.

There's a host of other manufactures that I've left off of both lists. Regardless, research whatever you're about to buy. Don't base the decision off of a few reviews. If it's a new manufacturer, you're much better off waiting and buying something that has a longer history. This is why you still see many long time reefers using Eheim, Tunze, and other tried and true equipment. Same reason many still use T5, MH, or a combo. It's what has worked reliably for them for years.

Do all those brands listed above make powerheads? Thanks for the reply, but it looks like you've got all the bases covered so to say. I was hoping you could boil it down a little more as far as which pumps are the best and how they stack up price wise to others. FWIW though the Koralia powerhead have worked very well for me over the years. I still have an old 540 I believe that's been in service for about 8 years now without any problems.

 

[RedStangGA]

REd, do you think a Eheim 1262 would be adequate on 100g about 5' of head and a 1/2" bulkhead. It would go in a 50g sump and needs to provide flow to a refugium and a dual media reactor. I just saw one new for $144 which I thought was a pretty good deal.

Honestly I think it will be a little short. If it was just feeding the tank I think you'd be okay but I'm not a huge fan of massive flow in the sump. Others would probably recommend 1500gph or more. The issue is I don't know what flow you'll need through the fuge and reactor. Even 100gph to each would mean you're likely only going to get 3-400 at best in the DT.

If you have the power heads to make up for it you might be okay but personally I'd aim a little higher.

For what it's worth, I was actually going to use the 1262 for my 220 build but then I decided to add a remote fuge and that required a little bit more flow from the return. Currently looking to go with a Sicce Syncra 5. and will switch it out if I don't get enough flow from it.

 

[RedStangGA]

Do all those brands listed above make powerheads? Thanks for the reply, but it looks like you've got all the bases covered so to say. I was hoping you could boil it down a little more as far as which pumps are the best and how they stack up price wise to others. FWIW though the Koralia powerhead have worked very well for me over the years. I still have an old 540 I believe that's been in service for about 8 years now without any problems.

Yeah, I guess I do. But, I'm not going to tell you what pump to get. My first hand experience with power heads is limited to Ecotech, Jebao, and Hydor. Hard for me to rate all of the available power heads by price when I only have experience with 3 manufactures.

Without knowing your tank size and plans for your tank it's hard for anyone to make a recommendation.

I wholeheartedly recommend MP10's. I loved them and had great success with them. As I mentioned, Hydor's can be a good value buy. Not everyone wants or needs the features of a vortech. You can throw a couple of Hydor's and get equivalent gph flow and they'll probably last a good long while.

By reputation alone, Tunze's seem to be a solid choice though not much, if any, less expensive than Vortechs.

What size tank do you have and what are your plans? SPS? Only softies?