Buffers can be made to lower pH, have no effect at a particular pH, or to raise pH.
Reef Builder claims to be mixed to about a pH of 8.3. So if the tank is at 8.3, they claim it has little impact on pH. If the pH is well be 8.3, it will boost pH. If the pH is above 8.3, it will lower pH.
What was the pH before the addition?
FWIW, I'm surprised that 2.5 teaspoons has much impact at all in a 200 gallon system. Did you let it mix in before measuring pH?