Reef Octopus NWB150 vs. Coralife Super Skimmer Needle Wheel 125

tarl1089

New member
I am purchasing my first protein skimmer for a new 75g that I am currently in the process of setting up. I am stuck deciding between the Coralife Super Skimmer Needle Wheel 125 which is on sale for $135.99 here:

http://www.drsfostersmith.com/product/prod_display.cfm?c=3578+20024+13924&pcatid=13924

I am also considering the Reef Octopus NWB150 because of the high recommendation I have seen in various forums. It is currently retailing for $224.99 on almost every site.

I am leaning towards the Coralife primarily due to budgetary concerns (I am budgeting a steep entry cost into this hobby as I am basically having to buy everything I need at once), and also because my LFS hyped it up to me (probably because it is the only protein skimmer they sell. They have it priced at $255 :eek1:). However, if the Octopus is absolutely better and will last longer, etc., I would rather just take the loss now than take a greater one later.

I am hoping someone more knowledgable than myself can help explain to me the difference between these two skimmers and help me make a decision.
 
I have had many skimmers over the years and the corallife was one of them. It will do the job, but it constantly required adjustment (very finicky). I purchased a SRO 6000 for my display tank and I was so impressed with it I purchased the NBW 110 for my frag system. The 6000 has been running for 9 months and the 110 for 6 months Never an issue with either. IMO bite the bullet and go for the Reef Octopus

Mark
 
Do not waste your money on the Coralife buy the Reef Octopus.

During my research, I have seen several comments that reflect a similar sentiment, and that's fine. I would just like to know why you think that so that I can make an informed decision on my own.
 
I have had many skimmers over the years and the corallife was one of them. It will do the job, but it constantly required adjustment (very finicky). I purchased a SRO 6000 for my display tank and I was so impressed with it I purchased the NBW 110 for my frag system. The 6000 has been running for 9 months and the 110 for 6 months Never an issue with either. IMO bite the bullet and go for the Reef Octopus

Mark

Thank you for your input. That is very helpful.
 
Back
Top