starting out

jjackson

New member
been doing alot of reading, I finished building a tank it is 20x24x10 tall.... My question is... can I only keep dwarf's or are there any larger breeds that would fit in my tank being only 10" tall... also was planning on tying this into my main reef tank which I keep at 76 degrees constant. going to go with live macros and most likely build a phyto and zooplankton reactor to dose the system through this tank....
 
With that temperature and tank height, dwarfs would be your only option.....and that is a HUUUUGE tank for dwarfs and feeding would be a challenge.

One other thought is having them tied into a system containing live rock, macroalgaes, etc would expose them to the risk of a hydroid infestation which is deadly.

With that said, it's really not suitable housing for any of the seahorse species IMO.

Tom
 
Thats about a 20 gallon tank. It is a little small for most species. Tying it in with a reef tank will help with water quality/stability.

You might get away with a pair of H. kuda. with that tank height, they will not breed.

Fred
 
arent hydroids bad in any reef tank.... fred thank you for your input... I just want them to be happy... not looking to raise babys... I am going to make it a macro tank no matter what with phyto being added to it via a reactor... whether or not I add seahorses is what I am debating right now....
 
if you can put a sponge over the intake/output, you may beable to keep hydroids out, but that won't really help.

With the ten inch height, seahorses are going to be limited, as others are saying. the smaller speices like cold water (less than 70* for capinses) maybe fuscus can do it? but they are VERY hard to find, so I'm told. Kuda just get too big (6-8 inches) erectus and reidi get even bigger at 8+ inches... growing up to a foot tall for reidi, and over ten inches if I remember correctly for erectus.

so, dwarves would be good, and there is one plus being plumbed into a reef tank: the copepods would help feed them. BUT, it needs to be VERY low flow, you need alot of them in a 20ish gallon tank, and your going to be supplementing thier feedings daily with brine shrimp. AND your going to need to keep them out of the display tank, with small screens and things like that.

so, I dunno as to your tank, if it IS suitable for them. You can look at other fish: a peacock mantis would be awsome in there, and he could care less about grasses:he may rearrange for ya, but...

or a jawfish tank, or a firefish tank... leaf-fish are pretty cool and would do GREAT in that tank (they would probably change thier color for ya too even)
 
Hydroids come in many forms and there are probably some in most peoples tanks. I have a tube building species in my tank, but it has never gotten out of control.

Fuscus are very difficult to identify, but I suspect they enter North America as H. kuda more often than we know.

Have you considered pipefish as an alternative to seahorses?

Fred
 
yes I have.... I am still debating the entire seahorse thing... I guess only time will tell.... pipefish would be cool.... who knows maybe it will end up just being a frag tank....
 
ok so I am thinking pipefish.... are they easier... or just more suited to the height of my tank... here is what I am thinking I would like

do they interact well with eachother... or should I pick just one species.... also how many in the tank at one time... either of one or multiple species?

sorry hope these arent stupid questions

Multibanded Pipefish (Doryrhamphus multiannulatus)

Dragonface Pipefish (Corythoichthys haematopterus)

Janss' Pipefish (Doryrhamphus janssi)
 
If you can get the search to work, there are a couple of really good pipefish discussions in this forum. You could also do it this way and display posts from the last year and wade on in. Just look for posts with pipefish in the title.

Fred
 
Back
Top