Stupid Is As Stupid Does

rmougey

Chair, MACNA 2014
I am not worthy. I have decimated a good portion of my reef tank and am pretty sure that the Reef Gods will be coming to revoke my remaining reef husbandry rights.

My reef has had a strange cyano problem. Not your normal slime algae, but one that seems to like high flow, well lit, quality salt water. It wasn't bad, just annoying. For a tank that's been up and running in one form for another since 1986, you'd think these things would be over by now. But no... it wanted to taunt me.

It was suggested that I try running some Chemiclean in my tank. I'm not one to add medicines to my tank, but it's made by a reputable manufacturer and it came as a suggestion from a fellow reefer, who has been much more successful than I had ever hoped to be with a reef. A quick search on RC didn't raise any concerns. So, I treated my tanks net volume with a single dose.

Today was my 48 hour water change. But as I walked by the tank, I noticed that things were not doing well. Clams were receding, fish were hiding, corals were closed. This was not good. I had turned off the skimmer, stopped the Ozone and had increased the flow rate on the Vortech to help with oxygenation. Evidently, this wasn't enough.

I pulled out the Python, hooked it to the utility sink and double checked that I had 100 gallons of available salt water. It was time for an emergency major water change.

After taking about 30 gallons of water out of the tank, I heard a strange sound emanating from the room with the utility sink. My mind noted the sound, but I was gazing upon my 5 clams, the youngest of which was 3 years old while 2 had been with me over 8 years.

The flow rate on the Python had slowed, so I called to my daughter to go turn up the faucet, thinking maybe I had a small rock trapped in the line. She returned rather quickly, asking if there was supposed to be water running all over the laundry room? Upon investigation, the stopper had fallen into the utility sink and found it's way to the lowest point, lodging properly in the drain. I had succeeded in placing at least 50 gallons of water onto the laundry room floor. Thank goodness for the floor drain behind the washer. The hall carpet though had not fared well.

Having fixed the flow problem, by removing the stopper, I returned to the tank, leaving my daughter with the wet vac.

After the water change, I started the skimmer, placed poly filters and carbon back on the tank and looked for any sign of improvement. It was not to be.

As of this evening, I have pulled the following from my tank:

1 Black/Gold Maxima
1 Teardrop Maxima
1 Tank Raised Blue Maxima
2 Crocea
1 Wantanabe Angel
1 Hybrid (C. resplendens x C. fisheri) Angel (My favorite!)
1 Tinker's Butterfly
1 Large Frogspawn
1 Large Pocillipora Colony
Several Acropora Colonys

I am missing:

1 Mystery Wrasse
1 Rosy Scale Wrasse
2 Scarlet Cleaner Shrimp
1 Helfrichi's Firefish
1 Male Mandarin

I do have several confirmed survivors including my Black Tang, a pair of wild Onyx Perculas, a P. springeri, my girl Mandarin and I noted my Porcelain Crab hanging out on my RBTA. Several corals are still hanging in, but only time will tell.

The cause of all this carnage? Stupidity and complacency. Whose fault is it? Mine and mine alone. I should have paid closer attention and I shouldn't have broken my mantra of not adding substances (chemical treatments) to the tank.

I sit here heartbroken. Embarrassed by my carelessness with the animals that I have worked years keeping healthy and happy. They deserved better.

The carpet will dry. Hopefully the remaining fish will appear and the corals will recover. But I may not recover from my own stupidity anytime soon.

It really was my Friday the 13th, and it just sucked.

-Rob
 
Yeah, me too.

I had my own bonehead move last weekend that resulted in some unnecessary losses...I guess I just wasn't secure enough to publish it to the world.
 
Chemiclean

Chemiclean

Hi Rob,

Sorry about your losses. I can relate in a small way to how you must feel.

I couple of years ago I had the same problem and, one of the reputable LFS encouraged me to use Chemiclean. I was excited about the possibility of finally resolving my problem.

Well as I started my water change after the recommended treatment period, three fish immediatly went into distress and my Foxface Rabbit fish took a quick trip to the sand and was dead before I could get a net out. I also lost a couple of other fish within minutes

No where near your losses but, I can feel your pain. Oh well, now you have some new treasures to look forward to.

Yes, I have read many success stories about Chemiclean and it is probably a great product but, I personnaly won't add it to my tank again.

Hal
 
Your loss

Your loss

I have been in the reef hobby for over 25 years. Many things in my care have perished because of good intensions, poor judgement, or misinformation that I applied to my reef world. New products, gadgets, miscalculation and yes stupidity. My wife wiped out a 10 year old reef tank once. She turned off the sump pump so she could feed the fish. The flow rate was about 1000 gallons an hour in a 55 and the food was getting swept into the overflow. She forgot to turn it back on and when I got home from work the next day all was lost. That caused me to quit the hobby for 5 years. I now have a "new" 3 year old tank.
Your loss is great. I feel your pain.
T.
 
Sorry to hear this :(
Did your pod population get decimated?
I hope there is enough to feed your mandarin:(
 
Thanks to everyone for their thoughts.... I'm still a bit shell shocked.

The good news is that the Helfrichi's and the Supermale Rosy Scale are well. The bad news is that the Mystery Wrasse is a confirmed loss.

Several of you have also offered to help me rebuild, offering critters and assistance. Those offers are greatly appreciated. But for the next several weeks, I'm just gonna let the tank recover before I even think about adding anything new.

Let's hope the other losses mentioned above stop here, for everyone!

-Rob
 
Wow all that time and energy, its got to be a disappointment. At least it was not a total loss. I've recently had problems with my heater and I've been lucky. You are human and nothing is perfect I've struggled with water quality problems and my corals are unhappy as a result. But I am still hanging in there.

You have years of experience and alot of investment into this hobby. Your tank will return, maybe now is the time for a new look or direction use the misfortune to your advantage.
 
Rob, Sorry to hear about your loss! I don't know what it is but I am on a slow recovery too since half of my tank crashed 3 weeks ago. I have some frags of the lps you got off of me a year or so ago if you need another piece of them let me know.
Martin
 
Thanks Martin,

That lovely green sinularia that I got from you a while ago is well.... and has grown to 5-6x it's original size. Unfortunately the LPS was lost in the disaster.

Thanks for offering and I'll give you a call when it's time, a few weeks from now.

-Rob
 
Back
Top