You can use a paper towel to remove oil from the top of a pot of spaghetti sauce. The scum in the aquarium is due to poor surface skimming. As geo pointed out, the water in your overflow box is too high, and therefore the box is not surface skimming. Secondly, the flow rate into the box in relation to its width may not be enough to keep the water surface skimmed. You may want to look into a wider overflow box.
Using paper towels to manually remove the scum is insane, as it will just keep coming back. Do YOU and want to be the filter or do you want the filtration system to be the filter? Using powerheads to keep the "scum" mixed back into the water column is not a good idea either, those are the organics that are going to cause nuisance algae growth. The surface of the water is great at binding organics, take advantage of that fact and get them into the overflow box and then to the skimmer where they can be removed.