To our new SPS Keepers

firefish2020

New member
The trouble with SPS:



Many of you have taken the plunge of late and have decided to try your hand at SPS keeping. A few of us have managed to have some success with these coral in the past but not without the headaches that they invariably seem to cause. For those who have not done so yet, I suggest you familiarize yourselves with Calcium and Alkalinity balance. Invest in a Kalkwaser Reactor or Ca reactor or both. Buy or build an Auto Top off system and run a temperature controller. I also suggest you keep an eye on your SPS daily and note any changes you may see. These guys are a bit less forgiving at times than the typical softies we deal with.

<b>RTN-STN</b>

Some acros for example can bleach within hours; reefers call this RTN (Rapid Tissue Necrosis). Though RTN is not in itself a disease it seems more a symptom of an unknown pathogen. RTN is not recoverable in my experience as the coral sloths off all of its tissue leaving a bleached white skeleton. STN (Slow Tissue Necrosis) however is another story. I have seen coral bounce back from this. Again it seems to be a symptom rather than a disease. STN seems to be caused by many common problems notably Ca and Alk problems.

<b>Red Bugs</b>

I have gone head to head with these creatures and many of you are infected with them and have no clue except a browned out coral that looses polyp extension. Red Bugs typically do not kill a coral outright, they devour it slowly over time and I believe can lead to its eventual death. They can be killed using the Interceptor treatment> http://reefs.org/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=45859
Some reports are coming out that “Tropic Marine Pro Coral Cure” can kill RBs, however I do not take the accounts at 100% legit just yet. If you have Red bugs use Interceptor and don’t guess, it works. Of course the best way to win against Red Bugs is to know your enemy well. Learn what to look for before buying an SPS, dip and quarantine new SPS. If buying at swaps or from other reefers ask lots of questions and examine coral carefully. Dr’s Foster&Smith claim 100% parasite free SPS, I have a few of these in the shop tank and have to say they are great quality.

<b>Acro Eating Flat Worms (AEFW)</b>

http://www.reefcentral.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=899108&highlight=aefw

Relatively new scourge that threatens to eclipse the Red bugs. These things seem unstoppable but a 15 minute dip in TNPCC is said to kill them. The experts are not weighing in just yet as Borneman has yet to receive a live sample of the pest to begin experimentation on. They are also hard to see, harder than RBs and so are a serious threat to any SPS keeper.

<b>Lighting and Waterflow</b>

The most common failure in SPS can be traced to lack of proper water flow and lighting. This does not mean you need 100 million watts and an ocean simulator to sustain your coral. I t means you need to research where your coral is from and try to emulate that environment. Most of our SPS are from reef flats. These flats get high light, far higher than we can give them and they get lots of flow. I used to think light was the most important thing for SPS but I know how that there seems to be a balance between light and flow. (More on this at the meeting if I remember).
20X tank turn over will do for starters but I like 30 to 40X turn over. Im not getting into the lighting debate of what's better, what's not. I can tell you that PAR is the most important thing to look at when deciding on lighting for your SPS system IMO. Do some research and ask questions.

That said SPS are one of the most rewarding and colorful coral in this hobby and once their demands are met they can provide years of incredible beauty to your tank. Buy smart and learn what it takes to keep these guys healthy and happy and both of you will be rewarded :)

Hope this is useful to some of you.
 
Last edited:
Ron,

How can you tell what your PAR rating is of your lights? I have T5 HO's, and some people will tell me these can grow high light SPS, but then other people tell me they will barely grow softies.
 
Sometimes a coral will just die, we have no idea why at the time, but I believe if we look hard enough we can find the answer(s). I think it requires a lot of investment in life support to keep a healthy SPS tank, that comment comes from many years of believing what I wanted rather than listening to what was known.

I grew SPS under PC at first, yes it can be done and some, particularly digitatas seemed to grow faster but the colors were horrible. The only colorful SPS I grew under PC was monti caps.
I also opted for the cheap way out on water flow (a bunch of maxi-jets). I later learned it would require far more than what these little pumps could do in my system. It is also important to provide good nutrient export on SPS systems, this should be a key goal to any keeper IMO.

After I invested in equipment to keep the system stable and give it flow and proper lighting I managed to get some great results.
However as Phil said , a bit of luck can never hurt when dealing with these coral :thumbsup:
 
Does cycling your tank longer help in the long run to eliminate nitrite and nitrate permanently? I know that it can come back because of overloading, but I never have any nitrate, or nitrite. I have 2 ocellaris clownfish, 1 small blue tang, a mandarin goby, a blue green reef chromis, and a yellow watchman goby. These are all small fish, but I do not run a real skimmer (I use a Skilter 250, just for added water movement, because t is a crappy skimmer) and the only other filter besides that Skilter is an Emporer 400. No sump, or refugium, etc. I've got about 50 lbs of lr or so, not exactly sure.
 
I have successful systems which cycled months and some that were set up within several weeks due to using established bio loads, no difference in any of them. Nitrates can come back later because of an imbalance caused by a shift in the nutrient import/export factor. Could be more fish added, a fish growing larger/eating more. More rock being added/removed etc. All these factors can influence your systems performance from what I have seen. You don't necessarily need a skimmer or mechanical filter for every tank if you know what is going on in the system IMO.

That said, most have no idea, or lack the patience required to balance a system properly to where a skimmer or filter is not required. It's a matter of what you "can have in your tank" rather than what you "want to have" in it. Don't get me wrong I think you have to have a skimmer on an SPS system as well as any serious coral reef tank. The exception would be a tank where the animal load is ridiculously to low for most hobbyists and the coral load would be primarily xenia based. Of course you could also have a similarly well balanced system with a heavy load of aiptasia in it, but I doubt many would like the looks of that.
 
Well, my 40 gallon capensis tank's chiller is having soem issues, so I may have to get rid of them. If I do, i'll get a warm water species of seahorse, and i'll have a refugium FILLED with xenia for filtration.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=8348316#post8348316 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Altpers0na
and here i was thinking "what have i done" by adding xenia to my tank....
LOL, I have thought the same thing since I became overcome with the stuff!
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=8346815#post8346815 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by firefish2020
The exception would be a tank where the animal load is ridiculously to low for most hobbyists and the coral load would be primarily xenia based.
Boy am I glad my serious coral overloaded aquapod with no skimmer, filter or xenia can't read :D
I keep everything "I want to have" that will thrive with pc lights. Seriously I'd use a skimmer in a heartbeat if they made a decent one to fit a 'pod but the tank does fine with 30% weekly water changes. Like you said it's all about balancing your nutrient input/export.
 
One day someone will make a decent skimmer for nanos, it's just not that hard to do and the market is waiting for it. A 30% weekly change is probably better than a skimmer on a small system anyway IMO, now both! Wow that would be great :)
 
Back
Top