What Eats Fish Poo ????

sjj80

Hater of Hair Algae
I currently have a Bare Bottom 90g and have two areas in my tank where all the fish poo collects, especially tang poo. I'm wanting to know what kind of invert I can add that will eat this stuff, I know that since my tank is bare bottom that starfish are out and none of my shrimp or crabs eat this stuff that I've seen. Any suggestions???
 
If the poo has any undigested food then the CUC may help. And if its collecting then you have low flow or bad powerhead placement or your overstocked and over feeding. Really more then on reason it collects. Can say it converts to ammonia and the skimmer and the LR and the SB will all help more then any CUC but only if its setup right.
 
its good to have a few spots where it collects to make for easy removal. Just syphon it into your filter sock and change the sock every few days and you will be fine.
 
If its collecting enough that you need to collect it then somethings wrong.IT shouldnt for more reasons i care to type.
 
Maybe I didn't explain clearly what I kind of answer I was looking for. I need a species of crab, snail, (tank cleaners) etc. to help consume some of the fish waste that gathers in certain areas of my BAREBOTTOM setup. Anyone who has a BB tank usually has an area of detritus accumilation, it's not unusual. For Flow I have two korallia 4s and a dual return pushing 900gph for a total of 3300gph, that's 36x the size of my tank (90g). I do weekly water changes to siphon out the waste and use an ER RS135 skimmer.

I'm wanting to add a tank cleaner that will help eliminate some of this waste, it's not that I'm being lazy, it's that I just want something to help eat this waste!
 
MB my reply went unread. None would be the most accurate answer.
It shouldnt collect and if it does then theres no CUC that can help.And many CUC perfer a SB and then many FOWLR stock eat CUC.

If it collects then its flow or filtration or amount of stock or feeding habits.

If there is any edible amount of uneatin food in the poop the CUC may find that but tripeling any CUC wont help.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=12479145#post12479145 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by demonsp
MB my reply went unread. None would be the most accurate answer.
It shouldnt collect and if it does then theres no CUC that can help.And many CUC perfer a SB and then many FOWLR stock eat CUC.

If it collects then its flow or filtration or amount of stock or feeding habits.

If there is any edible amount of uneatin food in the poop the CUC may find that but tripeling any CUC wont help.

Who said anything about my tank being a FOWLR, I know I didn't. Do you have a bare bottom reef tank? Sounds to me like you have a SB and don't understand how a BB tank works.
 
Re: What Eats Fish Poo ????

MB i dont understand.


<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=12478585#post12478585 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by sjj80
I currently have a Bare Bottom 90g and have two areas in my tank where all the fish poo collects, especially tang poo. I'm wanting to know what kind of invert I can add that will eat this stuff, I know that since my tank is bare bottom that starfish are out and none of my shrimp or crabs eat this stuff that I've seen. Any suggestions???
 
sjj80, there are some snails and crabs that might eat the waste, but take it in account that those animals create waste, waste doesnt just dissapear, its just gets recycled, you can try red and blue legged hermits.
 
You might be half right.Not sure where i got the FOWLR part. I associate BB with FO. Though i think it wouldnt change anything i said to much.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=12479283#post12479283 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by sanababit
sjj80, there are some snails and crabs that might eat the waste, but take it in account that those animals create waste, waste doesnt just dissapear, its just gets recycled, you can try red and blue legged hermits.

Thanks!!!!!!!!!! :D

I do understand that the waste will just recycle, however crab poo is a LOT smaller than my tang's poo so I figure it will reach the overflow and skimmer a lot easier that way. I don't have a lot of crabs or snails cause I wanted to see what was needed before purchasing. My tangs and fuge keep the algae in check so I'm looking for detrivores to eat their waste. Are the regular red (not scarlet) or blue hermits ok?
 
It needs to stay suspended long enough through flow to get captured by the filters you have like skimmer and LR and SB and CUC. Nass snails can help but they need a SB.
 
Funny how the same information redirected causes a positive response from then original thread started.People who look for a wanted reply rather then a more corrective one leads in unwanted results.


<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=12479354#post12479354 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by sjj80
Thanks!!!!!!!!!! :D

I do understand that the waste will just recycle, however crab poo is a LOT smaller than my tang's poo so I figure it will reach the overflow and skimmer a lot easier that way. I don't have a lot of crabs or snails cause I wanted to see what was needed before purchasing. My tangs and fuge keep the algae in check so I'm looking for detrivores to eat their waste. Are the regular red (not scarlet) or blue hermits ok?
 
Thank you. I cant understand why in a forum that taught me alot leaves threads like this hangin with wrong advice.



<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=12487524#post12487524 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by GSMguy
you need more flow not poo eating animal

do you even understand the BB system?
 
Back
Top