What is a good Ammonia test?

rjarnold

New member
What are you guys using to test for your ammonia levels? I have had 3 tests now, all reading different results. I bought one of those ammonia alert tags that you stick to the inside of your tank - I know this one isn't the most accurate so I had bought another test along with it. However, the alert tag has been reading alert the entire time (supposedly this is ~0.02 ammonia). The other test - I'm forgetting what brand it was now but it's a 2-bottle process, wait five minutes, and then compare colors...this test was horrible because it was never the color of any listed and it was always a guessing game as to which one it most closely matched or which two it was inbetween - my husband and I never came up with the same answer! But we reckoned that it was near 1.0 or over 1.0 every time.

So I replaced that test with a dip-strip test, the only other one available at the LFS. This test reads that the ammonia is well above 1.0.

So here's the deal - I've been doing 30% water changes every morning and night. Either there is a lot of die-off (which...I don't exactly see anything dying - all the snails, hermits, the mantis, etc are all doing fine) or these tests are just crap. And what of the hang-in one that still reads 0.02?

Bottom line - what is a highly reliable accurate ammonia test? I'm sick of fussing with these tests that are all giving me different readings.
 
Re: What is a good Ammonia test?

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=10037308#post10037308 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by rjarnold
What are you guys using to test for your ammonia levels? I have had 3 tests now, all reading different results. I bought one of those ammonia alert tags that you stick to the inside of your tank - I know this one isn't the most accurate so I had bought another test along with it. However, the alert tag has been reading alert the entire time (supposedly this is ~0.02 ammonia). The other test - I'm forgetting what brand it was now but it's a 2-bottle process, wait five minutes, and then compare colors...this test was horrible because it was never the color of any listed and it was always a guessing game as to which one it most closely matched or which two it was inbetween - my husband and I never came up with the same answer! But we reckoned that it was near 1.0 or over 1.0 every time.

So I replaced that test with a dip-strip test, the only other one available at the LFS. This test reads that the ammonia is well above 1.0.

So here's the deal - I've been doing 30% water changes every morning and night. Either there is a lot of die-off (which...I don't exactly see anything dying - all the snails, hermits, the mantis, etc are all doing fine) or these tests are just crap. And what of the hang-in one that still reads 0.02?

Bottom line - what is a highly reliable accurate ammonia test? I'm sick of fussing with these tests that are all giving me different readings.

Old school stuff...if it looks good it is good.....

If your test kit tells you something else, can it...get another...

and slow down on the water changes....too much is not good...if you tank looks happy it is....let it be....will cycle and be happy!

Richard TBS
 
Are you using Prime, Amquel or any water conditioner? (to neutralize chloramines, metals, etc.)

Water conditioners such as Seachem Prime tend to destroy the re-agents of some of the Ammonia test kits. If that's the case, the test kits would give false readings.

So If i was you I would assume that the ammonia Alert sticker is the most accurate indicator at the moment.

What are the brands of the the test kits?

I used Prime on my QT tank, and the Aquarium Systems FastTest is worthless and giving me readings over .8
 
Back
Top