whats the best cheap refractometer?

nightfire

New member
hey guys i was told i could get me a good refractometer from ebay and i saw em for 30 shipped,talked to sean today at EB and he said stay away from the ones with the blue handles,which can i buy thats cheaper and good,anything is better then a hydrometer i assume,are any of those on ebay really any good?
 
I'm not sure what the problems with the ones on ebay are, but I've got a $30 blue handle one that I've had for over a year, I've not got a simple problem with it.

It's a simple device, easy to calibrate, easy to use, etc... It be pretty hard for a company to screw them up.
 
sean said they get out of calibratstion very easily,im asking cause before i spend money id like to know,i do know id like one over this secound hydrometer i bought cause my last ones magnet came off
 
thats what i was freaking thinking too,if its just turning the screw whats da big deal.....dealing with bubble algae...now thats a prob lol anyways heres another question,mind you ive never used a refractometer,why do you need to calibrate it or should i ask,what does it do for the equipment?
 
I just went and looked at mine, I believe mine is exactly like the one you posted on ebay, black handle and all (thought it was blue). I have no problems with it. You calibrate it with a screwdriver, but I could see the thumbscrew ones being bumped out of calibration easily.
 
but what does calibrating it do? im not sure how they work,i only know you dab some water on the end of it,look through it and wa-la but why have to calibrate it?
 
So, a refractometer has a prism inside of it, and when you place a liquid on the glass, light goes through the liquid, slowing down and "bending" do to the properties of the particular liquid. When you look through the end of the meter, there is a small scale that tells you what the salinity of the water is, based on how much it bent. 1.026 salinity will bend more than than 1.024, and therefore reach a higher point on the scale.

The calibration screw adjusts the prism to a baseline to ensure that all of you measurements are correct. you can use distilled water to calibrate (it will measure at a fixed point every time, the instructions will tell you what), or you can buy calibration fluid, such as the stuff I have that is 1.026. I simply place a few drops on the glass, close the cover and make sure I don't have a bunch of air trapped, and then take a glance. If it's not seeing 1.026, I adjust the screw until it does. Then I know my water measurements are correct.
 
I got one of the ones from BRS. Wouldn't see any issues with the e-bay one either. Easier to use than a hydrometer and more accurate too.
 
thanks guys,now i understand why ya have to calibrate it,ive used the one at EB but never asked sean,i forgot,thanks for the helping hand if i can get one cheaper then 30 shipped from ebay then i'll do it but i doubt i can
 
Probably going to be the cheapest, and at the same time one of the most important purchases you make for your tank. hah Most refractometers need to be calibrated with 1.0264 solution. Mine specifically states do NOT use distilled or RO/DI water.
 
I just went and looked at mine, I believe mine is exactly like the one you posted on ebay, black handle and all (thought it was blue). I have no problems with it. You calibrate it with a screwdriver, but I could see the thumbscrew ones being bumped out of calibration easily.

Exact same here. I've not had any problems with the black handled refractometer, either.

Brandon
 
Probably going to be the cheapest, and at the same time one of the most important purchases you make for your tank. hah Most refractometers need to be calibrated with 1.0264 solution. Mine specifically states do NOT use distilled or RO/DI water.

This is a good point. You want it calibrated close to what you'll be measuring, IE 1.0264. :)

Brandon
 
Night, I am supposedly going to have a few at the swap. Black handled ATC10's, just like I use. Can be calibrated with RO water, and you can use a solution if you like as well. If you use a solution, make certain it states clearly on it that it is for calibrating a refractometer. BRS has a bottle of refractometer calibration fluid.

For anyone interested, here is reefkeeping magazines DIY calbration solution. AN interesting read.
http://reefkeeping.com/issues/2004-06/rhf/index.php
 
Back
Top