I'm having a similar problem, but want your opinion
I recently setup a 30 gallon tank with the help of my friend that is very fish knowledgeable. It has been up about 2 weeks now, and I have been using a few damsels to cycle the tank---salinity and everything is fine. Last night I noticed that one of my domino damsels has white spots all over him--I believe it to be ICH. I have read the "cures" and treatments for marine ICH, and my question is this: should I just break down the whole setup, and clean it well, and wait a week or so, and re-set it up? It seems to me the treatments for ICH are not 100%, and since the tank isn't even cycled yet, maybe the easiest way would be to just do it all over from the start. I would hate to lose the damsels, but wouldn't that be the best way of going about it? How long does ICH live out of the water? Because if I break the whole tank down, and clean it, should I let it all air dry and for how long? I don't want to reintroduce the ICH into it again after I set it back up. Also, I will cycle the tank differently this time around, using Biospira live bacteria from the LFS, and get it going faster, and use live rock this time also. Thoughts????