X10 & INSTEON

pjf

Premium Member
For the last 3 years, I’ve been using X10 and INSTEON products to control my aquarium lighting. My T5 daylight bulbs and my T5 actinic bulbs receive power from the INSTEON SwitchLinc modules in the picture below.
93304mini-SwitchLinc.JPG

My refugium’s power compact lamp runs on a RDP cycle and receives power from the INSTEON OutletLinc receptacles below. The two OutletLincs are new and have replaced two previous X10 receptacles.
93304mini-OutletLinc.JPG

To the left of the two OutletLincs is a GFI receptacle. The GFI protects all of the receptacles in the gang box. Unfortunately, the GFI attenuates X10 signals and makes controlling the OutletLincs a challenge. The X10 Mini-Timer in the picture below is able to control the SwitchLincs but is not able to send its signals to the GFI-protected OutletLincs.
93304mini-TimerLinc.JPG

To solve this problem, I recently purchased the Smarthome INSTEON TimerLinc in the picture above. The INSTEON signals from the TimerLinc are able to pass through the GFI filters and reach the OutletLincs. Apparently, INSTEON uses a different frequency to carry the commands. This frequency is able to pass through GFI devices to reach INSTEON modules that the X10 frequency cannot.

The TimerLinc has its advantages but it does have one glaring disadvantage. It can only control one INSTEON module or group of modules that turn ON or OFF at the same time. With one TimerLinc, you cannot control two INSTEON modules with different schedules. While it is controlling my OutletLincs, it cannot transmit a different schedule to the SwitchLincs.

I’m returning my TimerLinc in exchange for a computer-controlled INSTEON controller, the PowerLinc. The PowerLinc should be able to control both the OutletLincs and the SwitchLincs. I will let you know in a few weeks if the PowerLinc performs satisfactorily.
 
Silent Operation

Silent Operation

I should mention that the SwitchLinc and OutletLinc modules operate silently. When an X10 or INSTEON command is sent to these modules to turn the lights ON or OFF, there is no more noise than that made by a regular light switch.

This provides a much welcomed relief from the loud snap that occurs whenever an X10 outlet switches between ON and OFF states. When I first heard an X10 outlet turn ON, I thought someone had snapped a pencil in two.

In a couple of weeks, I plan to test the PowerLinc controller and post a consolidated review of various INSTEON devices on Reef Central. Please let me know if there is anything specific that you want me to address in the review.
 
It might be important to point out that another solution is to consider using Dual Band Devices if powerline signal attenuation is an issue. SwitchLincs and OutletLincs are both available as Dualband devices. Basically in addition to the powerline signal an RF signal is sent over the air. Dual band devices both send and listen for these RF signals.

They would certainly be a more reliable solution to this issue.
 
Back
Top