Working on my first acrylic projects, sump and internal overflow box. I'm using 1/4" cast acrylic. I started with the overflow box, much smaller 1x7x11, good practice. Everything seemed to go fine, turned out ok I think. I didn't use pins, just set the pieces on and applied WO4. It wicked into the joint and seems fine, a few tiny bubble here and there. Does this seem like it will be ok even with a few bubbles? All the bubbles are in the center regions, none at the edges.
For the sump, roughly 20"x16" by 18" tall again 1/4" cast, will this same technique work or should I use the pins? Why are pins used, is it because of the weight of larger pieces preventing the solvent from wicking into the seam? What is gained from this over just setting the piece in place?
All pieces were cut on a tablesaw with a Freud 80 tooth plexiglass blade. I scraped the overflow edges with a razor blade to get them smoother before bonding. I think I will router the edges for the sump before bonding those. Will that make any difference as for using pins or not?
In my experience the way you assembled your overflow box will be just fine. As for your sump, I would for sure use the pin method after you have used the router to dress the edge. The pins allow for the solvent to come into contact with both edges of the panels. It also allows for more solvent to help "melt" the acrylic of the edges. When you pull the pins there will be a fillet on both sides of the seam. If you dont use the pins you will starve the seam of the solvent needed to react to both edges and will not create a fillet.
This is just my experience!
The pros will chime in and correct my post if is not accurate. Good luck.
BTW I use a "down cut spiral cutting bit" on my router table to dress my edges. It works great for me.