i'm on a tight budget here since i'm only 18, and need advice on what skimmer to buy for my 75 gallon...i'm choosing between the asm g-2 or the euro-reef cs80 since both are around $200-250. Even though the asm has a higher tank rating, the euro-reef gets nothing but good reviews...which would pull more skimmate out, and which would you choose.
asm vs euro-reef...again
- Thread starter j_beau_13
- Start date
I own both a EuroReef and an ASM skimmer. I honestly believe that they perform about the same. The tank ratings on the ASM skimmers tend to be higher than they should while EuroReef may be a little conservative. A good idea may be to use the specs on the proper sized EuroReef skimmer and find an ASM skimmer with the same specs (height, diameter, pump, etc..) and ignore the ASM tank rating.
robsmith32
New member
not wanting to buy another in a couple years, put the extra $15 in and get a G3 instead.
purchased my g3 from asmskimmer.com for $263 to my door.
The g3 is much more skimmer than a G2.
purchased my g3 from asmskimmer.com for $263 to my door.
The g3 is much more skimmer than a G2.
I would also skip the G2 due to only a few $$$'s more & you get a G3 
I have one on my 90g
With the ER's, I definantly prefer the quality of my ER over the ASM. I think the ER is easier to clean/use however others feel ASM's are easier. I have a ER on my 260g
H20 has Blem ER's which you might want to consider, pretty nice discounts which would bring the price down to what a G3 would cost
I have one on my 90gWith the ER's, I definantly prefer the quality of my ER over the ASM. I think the ER is easier to clean/use however others feel ASM's are easier. I have a ER on my 260g
H20 has Blem ER's which you might want to consider, pretty nice discounts which would bring the price down to what a G3 would cost
CastleRock
Premium Member
Well if your gonna play football with it go with a ER, if you are gonna use it as a skimmer go with ASM
I LOVE my G-3
NorthernCF
Premium Member
Viggen, I have some older ERs and newer Ers. I think they use the same neck as the asm now. Perhaps some one can comment on this.
JB13,
I am skeptical of the extruded acrylic as well, but I have yet to find anyone who doesn't like their ASM or ER. So your best bang for buck will probably be an ASM if your going new.
JB13,
I am skeptical of the extruded acrylic as well, but I have yet to find anyone who doesn't like their ASM or ER. So your best bang for buck will probably be an ASM if your going new.
Schumacher
New member
ER=higher quality
ASM=cheaper
ER BLEM=Pure Pwnage
ASM=cheaper
ER BLEM=Pure Pwnage
todd kaminski
New member
I.M.O. I would go with euro reef. To me asm is just a cheap knock off. If your looking to save a little money buy a coralife super skimmer.
disbjohn
New member
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=7151669#post7151669 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Elite
I like my ASM (G2 /w Sedra 5000) .. Get the G3 /w the sedra 5000 pump. 3500 pump is a piece a crap
Did you have to do any mods to use the sedra 5000? I have the G2 and was considering getting the sedra 5000. I do currently have it set up recirculating styel.
Sorry for jumping in so late. I have both, and there is a difference in the thickness of the units, the ER thicker. But thats about it, both kick out lots of junk. I have the G4+ with the 9000. Both units with the gate mod. This brings me to the real question, why mod these, why don't these units come this way? Both manufacturers agree that the performance is enhanced.
I am just getting ready to start my 75 gallon as I am brand new to salt tanks and I purchased the Euro reef after reading a million posts here on RC. I purchased a Blem from h20tropicals.com. I havent received it yet but will let you know what I think of it when it comes in. This is the one I got: http://commerce2.i2net.com/able5stores/stores/33/product1.aspx?SID=33&Product_ID=559&
Paid about 165 after shipping
Paid about 165 after shipping
todd kaminski
New member
Yes Ive seen and had 2 asm. Compared to my euro reef there cheaply made. I'm not saying they dont work but to me euroreefs are built alot better and work better
hey smcdonn...are those used/refurbished skimmers they are selling?? how does your skimmer look and how can you tell what series the skimmer is...the one i'm looking at is http://commerce2.i2net.com/able5stores/stores/33/product1.aspx?SID=33&Product_ID=566&Category_ID=548
the specs make it sound like a CS100 model but the description on the website says its from the RS series which i've never seen.
the specs make it sound like a CS100 model but the description on the website says its from the RS series which i've never seen.
Similar threads
