There isn't really an overall best dimension, it just matters what will fit your style best. Personally, I would prolly get an 8' long tank, just to make sure there's enough swimming room for some of the bigger fish I would want. I have a 180 now, but I am still in an apartment, with a cross country move likely in the next few years, I don't want to get any bigger right now. When we get our house, I will either get an 8 or 10.