I don't understand your question. Obviously the overdriven icecap fixture will be brighter than the sunlight supply. The icecap reflectors are brighter too. So if your question was which light puts out more PAR or brighter light, the answer would be the icecap.
However, depending on the size of your tank and placement of your corals, either one could work. The icecap ballast will also burn your bulbs out faster and so you will replace your bulbs more often with the icecap.