I guess I should have been more specific. I prefer an overflow that is the length of the back of the tank, attached to both sides. The "shelf" would consist of a bottom and a front, the tank sides serve as the ends. A differintiated that from a "box" that has a bottom, front, and two sides; the box not being as long as the tanks back dimension and therefore having to be closed by means of end pieces.
In other words, the longer the better, and you can't get longer or easier than the length of the tank.