CTARS - Coral Growout Competition!!!

CTARS - Coral Growout Competition!!!

  • Zoas

    Votes: 38 88.4%
  • Mushrooms

    Votes: 1 2.3%
  • Leathers

    Votes: 4 9.3%

  • Total voters
    43
Alright boy and girls, it’s time to put your reefing skills to the test, we are hoping for a bi-annual showdown of your coral growing abilities. So whatever your argument or preference…MH over LED’s…or vice versa…two part dosing over calcium reactors…Lets put our corals where our mouths are…have some fun and grow some coral for the ultimate bragging rights!!!

So we decided to setup a friendly competition a coral frag grow out contest. I thought that we should give it a shot, we as club would have to "choose as a group" what type of coral to grow out. Keep in mind I would like to get everyone involved so easier corals like Zoas or other lower light corals for the 1st one and if it goes well then we could try SPS for the next round. I’m really leaning toward zoas as they are easy to get and frag, and it would be a good pilot to this contest.

The contest will be based on a percentage of growth not on total heads. This is due to not everyone may start with the same amount of heads. So for example you start with 1 head and grow 3 that would be a total of 4 heads and a 300% growth. If you start with 3 heads and end with 8 heads that would be a 5 head change and 267% growth. Highest percentage wins half of the pot (prize will be in the form of a gift certificate of winners choice). I believe this will be a lot of fun and some good bragging rights for the winner.

We will run this contest for 5 months; I would like to be started by the January meeting that way corals can be distributed. Please let me know who is interested and their preference of corals to be grown. I will also create an offical competition thread once things get under way!

There must be a few rules of course.

RULES

1. As a group pick a coral for the contest (If someone has a large colony to donate that would be awesome or compensation can be made)

2. A $5.00 buy in. Half of the funds generated will be given to the winner and the other half back to the club. PayPal will be set up.

3. A contest thread will be created to track the progress of each contestant. Each month, members will be asked to submit a photo of the frag to the thread stating how many heads the coral has.

4. We will do a monthly check in to show the progress of your coral. It will happen on the 15th of every month. In order to continue to participate in the competition you must post a picture and provide a polyp count. (there will be a grace period, but i'd like to keep it close to the 15th)

5. I will keep a running chart the shows the date and progress of each competitor with polyp count so we can track our growth

6. At the end on the contest the winner will be asked to do a small write up about what they did to get the best growth.

If I have missed something or there is a question, please feel free to ask it as I know I’m probably leaving a whole bunch of stuff out. Most importantly let’s have a lot of fun and continue to grow captive grown corals!!!
 
Excellent idea and plan
Just wish it wasn't zoas as I can't grow them worth a crap

It doesn't have to be zoas, I figured it would be a good way to introduce the contest and would be a way for everyone to get involved. Don't worry, after this one we will prolly do some sticks for ya :beer:
 
I have added a poll to the thread, as stated for the first go around, I think sticking to soft corals will be the best for now. I apologize in advance for those that are not a fan of these, but we will be doing another competition down the road!
 
As I was reading this I was wondering how it would work for SPS...zoas are definitely the way to go here! I'm all in on something like this for sure. Start our engines at something like 3 polyps...then see where we can take it from there? Or would we be starting at one polyp?
 
I would really like to start with multiple polyps but it is all depending on what we get to work with. I realize starting with 3 polyps of whatever has a better chance of growing more, but remember its based on % of growth not the number of heads grown.

I'm really happy to see folks interested already.

Depending on which coral is picked will determine some additional rules...(i.e. Zoas, baby heads will count as half, so if you have one adult and one baby, it will count as 1.5)
 
SPS growth could easily be measured by the mass of the coral itself. start them on a uniform base(frag plug), determine the initial mass of the coral, and weigh at the end to determine %mass increase from start
 
SPS growth could easily be measured by the mass of the coral itself. start them on a uniform base(frag plug), determine the initial mass of the coral, and weigh at the end to determine %mass increase from start

Wow that's a stellar idea, never thought of that.

Would you happen to be an engineer? Sounds like something the guys I work with would say.
 
Mike, I got a shet load of nuclear green. Trust me, all you need is one to start.. Lol I will donate. All off them buddy.
Let me know when we can do chalices. Because I will probably be dead by the time this 3G grows an inch!!!!$&@/
 
Mike, I got a shet load of nuclear green. Trust me, all you need is one to start.. Lol I will donate. All off them buddy.
Let me know when we can do chalices. Because I will probably be dead by the time this 3G grows an inch!!!!$&@/

Pauly, that is so generous and very awesome of you!!! I'd like to see how the poll does till January to give people a chance to express their opinions. Nuke greens are sweet too!!!

I hear ya on chalices...I can't grow them. Lol
 
I may have to join ctars just to participate in this. I bought one 1 p bkue hornet at the last farmers market have fraggeded 3 6 polyp frags off of it and still have about 70 polyps.
 
This is an awesome idea. My only thought was if we start with a different number of polyps, would say three polyps produce faster than one? I may be thinking about it the wrong way and the percentage thing will cover that, sometimes math messes me up. But three polyps or a mini colony will have more mat surface area for new polyps to sprout from, and the polyps will be working together to gather more energy for the colony. It seems like an exponential growth thing rather than a straight line?
 
This is an awesome idea. My only thought was if we start with a different number of polyps, would say three polyps produce faster than one? I may be thinking about it the wrong way and the percentage thing will cover that, sometimes math messes me up. But three polyps or a mini colony will have more mat surface area for new polyps to sprout from, and the polyps will be working together to gather more energy for the colony. It seems like an exponential growth thing rather than a straight line?

Justin,

This thought did come up, we are going to try and make everyone recieve the same amount of coral, if it ends up being zoas, I would like to start with 3 polyps each if possible.
 
Back
Top