I have both and they are totally different side by side. The original, Tyree/Hugo watemelon is pink, pink, pink, with greenish/yellow mouths and the green rim. The Aquascene Golden eye is more of a deep burgandy with gold/yellow eyes and the green rim. Very different. My pics on my website don't really illustrate the difference very good but you can check them both out on my "lps" page. The Aquascene golden eye grows faster than my watermelon as well.