do sps go thru withdrawl or miss the fancy setups

rogerwilco357

Active member
ok if you are dosing vodka and other nutrients or using zeo or any other balling method and your corals are vibrant and their color is peaking then. You frag off those fine specimens and sell em off to other people who are not dosing and just have your basic setup will these corals go thru withdrawal from the high life to the normal blue collar world? Is that what causes some corals to go from vibrant colors and crazy growth to browning up and just not being as happy as they where in dosed environments. just thinking I could be wrong and thinking of humans instead of corals or thinking of corals as sentient beings . Or maybe I just think too much lol. either way anyone here ever have that thought?
 
Why do you think going from a zeo or balling method to a "blue collar tank" would affect colors. I guess I have a "blue collar tank" according to you and my corals are as colorful as any zeo tank if not more colorful.
 
just noticed it

just noticed it

well i have seen a lot of frags go thru a withdrawal period in my opinion they are a lot like us if they are used to cappuccino's and caffeine and go to a de-caf environment i would think they would have some type of withdrawal not necessarily meaning that all regular tanks will produce no color just the frags coming from enriched environment. My sons tank produces great color and has a basic setup no dosing . but his friends tank is dosed and when he gets frags i noticed that some will turn brown and take 6 months to color up maybe the different nutrients or lighting or maybe they just miss the vortechs ,balling and caviar? lol
 
It's my opinion that the change in environment causes the stress and color change that your refering to. It doesn't/shouldn't matter where it comes from, most all corals take time to adjust to a tank. The longer in captivity the less the change effects the coral. I think it has little to do with husbandry methods because we all have the same ultimate goal. Hope this helps.
 
If they really missed the fancy setups and would "brown out" in anything else then all of our tanks would contain brown corals. The ocean is much better than any tank out there. Being moved from the ocean to an aquarium would seem like a step down.
 
I personally think that Zeovit colored corals are a sign of stress. That translucent coloring is universally acknowledged as a sign of stress by researchers doing research on corals in the field. Corals DO NOT look like that in nature. I also am a blue collar reefer. My colors are not the same as a ZEO tank, but I think they are ok

ChadBlueMilli7-21-2008.jpg

chadstricolor7-21-2008.jpg

Rosemilli7-21-2008.jpg

PinkProstratd10-21-07.jpg

Bluetort10-4-7.jpg

Lasoettemacro.jpg
 
dvmsn, your brown corals are just so ugly..

I agree 100% with this
"It's my opinion that the change in environment causes the stress and color change that your referring to" ]

stability is the key. get each of your parameters within the accepted "operating window" then never let them move. any big change in flow, light, nutrients, zeo, etc. likely will cause tempoary brownouts.
 
Granted you should have your environment within reccomended range. I.E. P04 < .05 IMO.. Nitrates... I know guys that have 20ppm Nitrates and their colors are amazing... I'm still on the fence about 0 nitrates or having a few. Depending on the species of SPS the ultimate water conditions vary and its fairly impossible to have the BEST coloration in ALL your corals at the same time.

Any time I add a new coral to my tank there is definatley a color shift 99% of the time. I think this is influenced by several things. (Lighting, Flow, Nutrient levels, Tank Chemistry Diffs). Some corals color back up quickly and others take a longer time. If I were you I'd give it a couple months. Take pictures of them so you can see the diff over time. When you see them every day you cant really tell how they are changing. But most of all make sure your basic parms are in line. If you have high Nitrates and P04 of course your gonna have brown corals.

As far as Zeo colors go, Its a little annoying to me when people immediatley assume Zeo = washed out, pale corals. Zeo is just like any supp program. You can tweak your corals coloration in any which way you prefer. There are MANY supps that do different things. Some make colors darker and some lighter. Also I think some run their Zeo harder than others and makes their tanks nutrient defficient. Personally I dont like it. That is why I do NOT do Zeo supps that lighten. These would be B-Balance and Zeospur. Sponge Power, Amino Acids and Pohls-Xtra are my favorite supps from Zeo.

I like DEEP RICH coloration. I would like for my coral to have the deep rich AND the irridecence (sp) achieved from using some supps. I'm NOT afaid of feeding either. When I'm home I feed the living heck out of my tank. Some of my fish are darn near obese. Otherwise I rely on my auto feeders when I'm out of town.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top