Fish that eat valonia?

maxxII

Super Housemonkey!
I'm beginning to get a valonia outbreak in my tank, and I'm not happy with that. I've tried emerald crabs in the past, with no luck. I've heard that rabbitfish will eat valonia, but I've also heard that about zebrasoma tangs and acanthurus tangs, and neither the purple tang nor the convict tang in my tank will touch the stuff....


Any suggestions?

Nick
 
I would identity the source of the algae outbreak.. Before I would use livestock to control the problem. Fish, crabs, snails, sea hairs are all hit and miss...

Correcting the problem is much easier, and you will learn how the balance of a reef system works in the process...

Happy Reefing
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=12569050#post12569050 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by ricks
I would identity the source of the algae outbreak.. Before I would use livestock to control the problem. Fish, crabs, snails, sea hairs are all hit and miss...

Correcting the problem is much easier, and you will learn how the balance of a reef system works in the process...

Happy Reefing

Tank is an Oceanic 120, BB with a 55 gallon sump, and 20 gallon H plumbed in. Total system volume is about 170 gallons. Chaeto is in the sump, the 20 H has a 2 inch sand bed.

DkH 11.2
Ca 420
Mg 1520
Salinity is 1.026
Temp is 82F
Nitrates are undetectable

Two water changes have been done this month so far:
a 15 gallon water change on 05-04-08
a 20 gallon water change on 05-14-08

The chaeto in the sump is growing, but has only needed to be thinned out twice in the year this tank has been up. Glass needs to be scraped once a week to remove the film of algae growing on the glass....so there are some nutrients available to promote algae growth.

I have a Tomini tang, a convict tang, and the purple tang in the 120 for algae control, in addition to a large diadema urchin. There is a large Derasa clam, (approx 10 inches) and a large crocea clam, (approx 5 inches). Acros are doing fine and growing, as is my Ritteri anemone (had it for over 2 years, one year in this tank). My percs mate every two weeks. My Indo Pacific Regal Angel eats from my hands.....so this isnt exactly my first experiance with reefkeeping, and I've got a good grasp of how the balance of a reef system works.

With the above information, please tell me how you think I might be able to restrict nutrients further to the valaonia and eliminate them. About the only other thing I can think to do is to add a Phosban reactor to the mix cause I cant test for phosphate....


Suggestions??????????????????????????????????????????????

Nick
 
My naso took a liking to the stuff, but it took a while for him to see that it was food.
 
Never really had a problem with valonia but, when I gave away my Red Sea sailfin tang it started to pop up here and there.
 
Valonia will grow well in low nutrient tanks as well.

Thanks Dave...thats what I remembered reading as well....
Those Emerald Crabs I got from you didnt touch the stuff...

My naso took a liking to the stuff, but it took a while for him to see that it was food.

Hop, dont really have room for a Naso, even if I removed the Purple and the Convict tang....sorry to hear that yours didnt make it.

Never really had a problem with valonia but, when I gave away my Red Sea sailfin tang it started to pop up here and there.
Sailfin tangs love it.

Hmmm.....my wife has liked the way Desjardinii tangs look...

"They're very stylish, very retro looking! I like it!"

Might look into that....

Nick
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=12573604#post12573604 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by maxxII
Thanks Dave...thats what I remembered reading as well....
Those Emerald Crabs I got from you didnt touch the stuff...



Hop, dont really have room for a Naso, even if I removed the Purple and the Convict tang....sorry to hear that yours didnt make it.



Hmmm.....my wife has liked the way Desjardinii tangs look...

"They're very stylish, very retro looking! I like it!"

Might look into that....

Nick

Sailfin Tangs are very hit and miss with it as well, mine doesn't touch the stuff and many others I've seen don't either.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=12572945#post12572945 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Nanook
Sailfin tangs love it.
Nook,
I believe only Red Sean Sailfins will eat it...I may be wrong on that.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=12574855#post12574855 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by SeanT
Nook,
I believe only Red Sean Sailfins will eat it...I may be wrong on that.

Mine is a Red Sea Sailfin. I want to rephrase what I posted earlier... My Tang and Foxface do not seem to eat Ventricaria ventricosa which is what usually just gets called Valonia around here. I do feel they eat Valonia aegagropila though I've never witnessed it. I only feel this way because it's in my tank but I only find it when I pull rocks apart. On the exposed surface of the rocks I don't find any, just plenty of Ventricaria ventricosa, so I assume one or both of my fish will eat it.
 
Back
Top