glass/acrylic pros and cons

kohan

New member
What is the better/ safer to use while keeping mantis shrimp in a glass or acrylic aquaium, and why or why not.

There doesn't seem to be a lot of literature on the internt reguarding this subject. However it seems to me that if your mantis decides to tap on the side of the tank either way you're screwed.

tia
 
I've posted on this topic at this site dozens of times over the past three or four years. Search under "acrylic".

The quick answer is that unless you are keeping a 6 inch O. scyllarus or 12 inch Hemisquilla, you probably have nothing to worry about provided that you are using a standard commercially produced glass or acrylic aquaria that are the appropriate size for the stomatopods you are keeping. The reason I say this is because occasionally people (myself included) will construct a photographic tank from thin window glass. Even an 8 cm G. chiragra can break one of these tanks and I use them knowing the risk.

Large smashers usually cannot break an acrylic tank, but they can dent it. Sometimes they will decide to dig in a particular corner and repeatedly strike the same area. The result is a pitted acrylic wall that is not very attractive.

Glass is not pitted but edges can be chipped. A large smasher trying to dig in a corner will often come to the wall and try to break through the obstruction just as it would a piece of coral rubble in the field. The result can be a chip that can cause a leak. Again, I stress that this would only happen with something larger than a 7 or 8 cm Gonodactylus or a large O. scyllarus or Hemisquilla.

In my 37 years of keeping stomatopods in my lab at Berkeley and at various marine labs, I can count on one hand the catastrophic aquarium failures I have had caused by a stomatopod knocking out the side of a tank. We have had a few more leaks from chipped corners and edges (and lots of broken heaters and tank dividers).

If you want to play it really safe, I recommend lining the bottom edges of a glass tank with 1/8" thick acrylic. You don't need to cover the entire bottom, perhaps just a 1- 2 inch strip around the bottom edges. If a large smasher does decide to take out its frustrations while digging, the worst that will happen will be a few dents in the acrylic.

Roy

p.s. I have been occasionally asked what was the worst tank failure I've had. In the mid-70's we used a lot of 35 gal "Instant Ocean" systems. These were made from marine plywood with a viewing window placed in the front. The glass was thick double glazing. I had a large male O. scyllarus about 6.5 inches long that was quite aggressive. One day a a scientific journal editor was visiting my lab and to impress him with the pugnacity of stomatopods, I started teasing the animal with my finger on the glass. The animal made a swimming attack, struck the center of the glass window and broke it. I've always had a fond place in my heart for that animal because its exploits were responsible for my being asked to write my first major paper about stomatopods (1976, Scientific American).
 
i have noticed that my peacock is getting more aggressive lately, she will charge me a little bit at night but not during the day
 

Similar threads

Back
Top