We ended up catching three stores:
Aquarium Arts - Older store with a descent mixed bag of everything. What really stood out was the customer service and staff. Excellent! Not only knowledgeable but friendly. Good selection of fish and some more "unique" coral.
Coral Reef Imports - Small store but nice selection of coral. Lights were really set to "pop" everything (Royal Blue insanity). Sales associate opened the store late, so we didn't stick around too long.
The Reef Monsters - Very nice store and modern. Prices were a little high. Unique stock but once again, everything other than the fish were "blued out" with lighting. We felt really sorry for a female mantis who was being kept in a jar. Yeah, we know, they will kill and eat everything, but since they had numerous single-celled aquariums for livestock, put her in her own.