Help to ID these two Softies

calk me Q

New member
NPS? This picture comes from one of the vendors who mentioned this species is not common in Asia?? On the first sight i thought it was a photosynthetic one however i found the white polype extruding that makes me think it a NPS. Any idea?


This one is very common in chinese market which belongs to NPS, however i dont know whether they are ez to keep?

Looking forward to your guys help


Acros & Wrasses
Second one looks like a Chili Coral (Nephthyigorgia sp.)

Not sure one first, kind of looks like an orange variation? They are both NPS, you should ask in the NPS section for better information. :)