How long did you wait to add corals?

lalaallieu

New member
This guy at my LFS today that I talked to told me I had to wait a year to put corals in my tank. I've never waited a year ever on my previous tank and this guy was super insistent that I was wrong for wanting to put corals in my tank when my cycle was complete. How long did you wait? He said he's starting a 150g tank for just corals but he's going to wait a year before putting corals in.

Sent from my Pixel using Tapatalk
 
He's probably overprotective of his corals in his store, I waited after the cycle. Out of maybe 5 or 6 corals that I got in the beginning 1 is still in the tank. Alot of things can go wrong in the first year without knowing how your tank is and to make it stable. That's why I would think he was that way.
 
Softies you can add right after, LPS I would wait a bit. SPS really do way better in a fully established tank, and a year is about right for that.
 
Corals are safe to be added when your tank has fully cycled (4-6 weeks) + another 4 weeks of stable water as to temp, SG, Calc, Alk, MG, nitrate and phosphate 0 + availability of good light in the correct spectrum (leaning to the blues).....then it is safe to add a few corals at a time so your filtration can keep pace with the new inhabitants. Keep in mind, that a mixed SPS tank with softies is very challenging....better to go one or the other not both....and softies are very hardy, inexpensive and come in tons of forms....
 
I didn't buy any corals, and I don't have a test kit for CA, mg and all, but nitrite and ammonia are 0, nitrate at 10ppm and pH at 8.4. Just wondering if the guy at the fish store is correct.

Sent from my Pixel using Tapatalk
 
If he waits a year to put in any corals that is the first time I have heard of that. I put in a bunch of Zoas and lps shortly after the tank cycled. Also added a couple of fish.
 
I start adding corals (hardy polyps, leathers and stoneys) within a day or two after water goes in. Corals compete with algae for nitrogen and phosphate and the sooner they get started the quicker you you can get past the algae cycles of maturing a reef system. Hopefully you used some live rock to help get some of the cryptic animals like sponges, you don't need a lot but some is very definitley called for in my experience and research. And don't fall into the trap of thinking the colloqial terms "SPS" and "LPS" denote husbandry requirements, they might be convienent jargon to use in a conversation but have no relavance when trying to determine what an animal wants to thrive.
 
IMHO, it depends on several factors, the first being the experience level of the aquarist. If you are just starting out, then I would suggest allowing your tank to mature a little, and in the meantime, get to know the in's and out's of successful marine aquarium keeping. If you have been keeping marine tanks for years, then you already (should) know what to look for and how to take care of problems that will arise.

How you set your tank up plays a big part as well. If you started with dry rocks and sand, then allowing the beneficial bacteria and larger lifeforms to establish themselves will go a long way in determining your long-term success. If you are using already established live rock then you have already gotten past a large hurdle. When I started my current 120DT, I used mostly dry rock and sand, but added several choice pieces of rock from one of my other tanks that had been running for some 20+ years and seeded the new, dry sand with a couple cups of sand from the same established tank. There was no perceptible cycle at all, and combined with my previous hard earned experience, I had no qualms about adding SPS frags within the first week.

About what you should start out with - you need to think ahead to what you want the tank to be 5-10 years from now and choose appropriately. Can you start out with "easy" corals like many of the soft corals/mushrooms/zoanthids? Sure, but they can also end up being a major problem if/when you make the switch to more demanding species because most of the "easy" corals are not only more tolerant of less than perfect water and sub optimal lighting, they can spread like weeds and then become difficult to get rid of.

hth!
 
I waited 3-4 months and began adding corals outside of a couple zoas here and there in my old tank and had 0 trouble with anything I added after that. Just transferred everything to a 120 and everything I transferred made it as well too. I felt like 3 months was a good solid number for being patient
 
Back
Top