How often SHOULD you buy new fish/etc?

Sk8r

Staff member
RC Mod
This is of course a matter of personal choice, but consider that tanks have their limits, and quarantine is a relatively brief necessity---once you have your tank population set and stable (and they're not eating each other or your corals: research!!!!) you can fold away that extra pair of tanks and settle down to a whole new phase of the hobby.

Yes, there is life beyond fish-shopping and qt. Make your choices sensible, know your adult sizes, and then, yes, you have a tank which, given a) good water quality b)appropriate fish c) decent lighting d) compatible inverts, hey---you can now just farm your tank, feed it and watch it grow for years with no exposure to parasites and noxious bacterial infections.

Is there going to be the Grand New Tank someday? Yes, but don't buy fish for it yet. Just do this one well. You may fold this tank into the GNT eventually---wall space isn't infinite, but meanwhile enjoy the 30 gallon reef or the 100 gallon fish-only for what it is, and measure your success by how long you can have your tank running well with healthy inhabitants. The hobby IS mostly about that, and you will learn a great deal from your 'running' tank---the solution to little problems, better growth, nicer arrangement. There's lots to do and experience. Every time you buy a new fish or coral, you DO put all the others you have at risk, minor or greater depending on your practices, but even with the best practices, things can go amiss. So get set up, get through the 'qt's always running' phase, and just experience the 'it's running well!' phase. It DOES exist.
 
I am in the buying fish and coral with no QT phase. Stay tuned for my "I have Ich, what to do?" thread ;)
 
All I can advise is 'Do it fast and then quit buying while you're still ahead.'
 
Some really good points here. It's amazing what a little extra work and care upfront will do for your tank(s) and fish in the long run. Being able to look back at the fish you've had for years and how they interact and develop their own personalities over time is pretty cool.
 
One more purchase then done...fingers crossed.

Samesies. But now that everyone else is settled in, idk, I'm kinda reluctant to buy the last guy and confuse everyone again. I might chicken out and just be happy with what I've got lol
Buying fish is fun at first but it's also stressful and qt'ing sucks.
 
I am pretty proud of myself. I saw my first leopard wrasse at Petco the other day. My immediate thought was it is your duty to save this beautiful fish before I knew anything about it. Luckily I caught myself looked it up and realized it wasn't for me or my 30 gallon tank.
 
I am pretty proud of myself. I saw my first leopard wrasse at Petco the other day. My immediate thought was it is your duty to save this beautiful fish before I knew anything about it. Luckily I caught myself looked it up and realized it wasn't for me or my 30 gallon tank.

I have a leopard wrasse going through TTM right now. Its certainly not a fish for the regular hobbiest, and I would fully believe the LA recommendation of being expert only. Just one round of prazipro caused it to completely wig out.
 
I finished my fish shopping about 15 months in. I was really worried that I would be less excited without new fish to buy, but once I got to the point where my tank felt "full". I no longer have a desire for new fish because I know it would mess up the beautiful community I have created.
 
THat's pretty well true. You decide on your situation, on your desired community, and you start bringing them in. In a situation where fish will start small and grow quite large, you may bring them in together and just do it nearly all at once because the tank is big and fish are not. In situations where you are buying adult or almost adult fish, in a smaller tank, you may need to pace it out.
 
The hunt for the 'perfect fish' is taking up most of my hobby time nowadays.
But until I get the one I'm looking for, all other fish are off the table.
Unfortunately all online site have been OOS for months.
Local LFS aren't having any better luck.
 
Back
Top