A simple answer. Yes, overfeeding can cause an ammonia spike. Products like Selcon are extremely rich foods. If more organics go into a system than what the innate bacteria can immediately deal with a "œbacklog" in the nitrogen cycle will occur. Most hobby test kits have trouble displaying low levels of ammonia in saltwater while higher, more lethal, levels are more accurately read. IMO, API's liquid NH3/NH4+ test is good enough in determining whether the chemical is present or not. Finer resolution can be obtained with the use of more expensive tests. IMO, the best kits to read the various forms of Nitrogen (NH3/NH4+, NO2-, NO3-) we care about are produced by LaMotte. Any amount of detectable Ammonia or Nitrite on hobbyist test kit is reason for concern and, if confirmed, immediate action should be taken.