ich mortality rates

BigRedDog1934

New member
i am wondering if it is possible for fish to survive ich? i have a small tiger goby that i noticed had ich right before i had to leave town for a few days. i have since returned and found that bout 90% of his white spots are gone. is it possible that this dude has just fought it off?

i have to admit this is entirely my fault. i have yet to set up a hospital/quarentine tank and added a royal gramma from petco.
 
I have had many fish survive Marine Ich. I normally don't do any treatments unless it is a severe outbreak. Top notch, stable water quality and lots of healthy, nutrient rich foods, and almost all of my fish have made it through Marine Ich outbreaks.
 
His being a goby is very much in your favor: they almost never get it, and if they do, usually a few spots and its gone. Blennies, gobies, and dragonets are bottom-dwellers, and tend to encounter it a lot more than most fish: they seem to have a natural defense.

Ever since I have become very meticulous about water quality [dating back to the 1980's] I have not lost a fish to ich or velvet. I've lost fish to accidents, predators, and things like that, but any ich outbreak I had was not tank-wide and did not result in fatalities. It's not all luck: I keep more blennies and gobies than other species [but not exclusive] and I also have a lot of corals---I have my own notion that corals may actually eat the freeswimming phase of this parasite: they eat everything else in that size range. I don't know why that should be an exception. So for whatever reason, good water, corals, and a lot of fish who don't get it, I've lucked out. Any outbreak I've had, and I can about count them on the fingers of one hand, has been brief and just as you describe. I do feed garlic, believing in belt and suspenders, whenever I have a new fish in the tank.
 
thanks guys this makes me feel better for the little guy. i have had a hell of a time with fish in this tank. two clowns got the brook and the royal gramma disappeared one night too. the little goby is a tough one, though, with plenty of character. i have only had the tank for about three months but have become attatched to the little dude.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=8457303#post8457303 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Sk8r
His being a goby is very much in your favor: they almost never get it, and if they do, usually a few spots and its gone. Blennies, gobies, and dragonets are bottom-dwellers, and tend to encounter it a lot more than most fish: they seem to have a natural defense.

Ever since I have become very meticulous about water quality [dating back to the 1980's] I have not lost a fish to ich or velvet. I've lost fish to accidents, predators, and things like that, but any ich outbreak I had was not tank-wide and did not result in fatalities. It's not all luck: I keep more blennies and gobies than other species [but not exclusive] and I also have a lot of corals---I have my own notion that corals may actually eat the freeswimming phase of this parasite: they eat everything else in that size range. I don't know why that should be an exception. So for whatever reason, good water, corals, and a lot of fish who don't get it, I've lucked out. Any outbreak I've had, and I can about count them on the fingers of one hand, has been brief and just as you describe. I do feed garlic, believing in belt and suspenders, whenever I have a new fish in the tank.


I'm in the same mind set as you. And when I speak on it... people think I'm crazy. I believed the corals had to help... they catch food why not other critters? I used to have my tank filled with corals. My water quality is great and I feed my fish well. Never had any problems. That is until recently. I don't have many corals anymore and I clipped my puffer's teeth.. in doing so, I had to sedate the puffer. Used clove oil. A few days after treatment 3 fish have marks all over their bodies from scrathing on the live rock.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=8457303#post8457303 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Sk8r
His being a goby is very much in your favor:

you mean 'in the gobies favor',,right?
 
Back
Top