ick or velvet under the microscope

Chicago

New member
ok.. tell me your opinion.. ick or velvet. taken from body mucas after death of morish idol.

morish%20scrapping%20%2010.jpg
[/URL][/IMG]

morish%20scrapping%20%203.jpg
[/URL][/IMG]
 
From the way it moves my vote would be on a ciliate and not a dinoflagellate

I agree. Ich trophonts "tumble" under the epithelium, which is why they are so irritating to fish. Amyloodinium uses rhizoids to affix itself to the fish, and doesn't move when attached.
 
That would be my guess. Brooklynella and Uronema are pear-shaped. Crypto trophonts are round like the specimen shown in your video.
 
Thank you for the reply OK so here's my question. Is it possible that that is a dinospores for velvet. I asked because my scribbled has a dusty like appearance and it doesn't really look like crypto..aka saltwater ick. The strange thing is none of the wrasses have any signs of ick or velvet nor does the small blue face angel or even the Chevron tang
 
No. Velvet is not a ciliate, and the organism in your video above is clearly a ciliate like crypto. It could also be Brooklynella or Uronema. I would lean toward crypto, though. Definitely not Amyloodinium (velvet).
 
Last edited:
crazy thing is.. body of my scribble and the foxface have no signs of ick.. and yet they are breathing hard and male scribble is hanging at the top of the tank tonight.. they are all eating well and hungry.. go figure.. I would think this was velvet if not for the footage on the microscope..
 
I wouldn't be so quick to discard velvet after the examination of one dead fish. Many parasites leave a dead fish. Cryptocaryon needs a bit of time to leave since it in inside the skin. Amyloodinium just needs to retract it's "straw" and is off to "greener pastures".
Another difference is that Cryptocaryon has to encyst to get to another fish even if it hast to leave early. Amyloodinium, if less than 24 h on the host, can leave one fish and directly infect another.

The only way to be sure would be a live biopsy of the gills (if you have the guts for that).

Another thing: I have never seen fish breathe heavy due to an occult or visible low level Cryptocaryon infection. Usually an ich infection needs to be pretty progressed to cause rapid breathing.

Amyloodinium on the other hand usually starts with affecting the respiratory system heavily before showing on the skin.

I would give these fish a prophylactic freshwater or formalin bath to dislodge eventually present Amyloodinium. If the fish have velvet you should find something in the bath water (maybe strain it to a sufficiently fine micro sieve).
 
still trying to figure this out.. took some scrappings from the female scribble this am. I can see the ick. any of you see other bad guys..

not sure what the yellow spots are.. might be just some dust but noticed looks like limited to on the scales. have yet to see a pic of velvet so not sure.

anyways.. on of the videos we have a speedy ick.. flying all over the place.

next video has lord humungas .. ick. 50 times larger.

other is a close up

input welcome.. thanks






 
Back
Top