Iodine dosing information help separate facts from good marketing!!

jlinzmaier

Premium Member
Brightwell aquatics sells an iodide product and this is the information they post about iodide dosing in reef aquariums:

Technical Background
Presence of iodine is vital to hermatypic invertebrates because it is used to detoxify excess oxygen produced by zooxanthellae. This oxygen irritates sensitive tissue. Corals and clams that appear to shrivel or close under intense lighting are likely attempting to shade their zooxanthellae symbionts to reduce the rate of oxygen production. Iodide essentially bonds with oxygen to form non-toxic iodate, relieving the need to shield zooxanthellae and enabling the host organism to open more fully.
The predominant form of iodine in seawater is iodide. The natural seawater concentration of all iodine species combined is approximately 0.06 ppm, classifying it as a minor element. Even in this small concentration, iodine is required for survival of fishes, crustaceans, macroalgae and kelp, and hermatypic invertebrates alike. The importance of iodine in a reef aquarium cannot be overstated. Iodine binds rapidly with latent organic material and is passively removed by aggressive protein skimming and the use of organic-adsorption products such as activated carbon and specialty resins. The combined biological and chemical depletion of iodine necessitate that its concentration be monitored and the aquarium supplemented as needed. The rate at which iodine is extracted from the water is determined by the stocking density of reef-building livestock, type of lighting, and other biological, physical, and chemical conditions. Once the rate of iodine uptake in the aquarium has been determined, the proper dosing rate of this product can be easily calculated.
All Brightwell Aquatics liquid water care supplements are made with purified water and high purity materials. We develop formulae for aquaria based on empirical data, using observation and measurement rather than theory.

Is that factual or merely good marketing (I'm particularly interested in the claims in the first paragraph)???

Thanks.

Jeremy

Jeremy
 
Jeremy, the iodine level in most reef tanks is usually above NSW levels, therefore dosing iodine is not needed except for maybe some specialty corals.

Marketing hype as usual IMO.

I'm sure Randy will have more to say about this in the AM. :)
 
I do not dose any. For years I did, and then I stopped and saw no change. Many reefers have repeated that "test" with the same result.

Sometimes that "observation test" is far more important than any kit we can buy to give us a numerical measurement!!

Thanks for the links to the articles Randy. The only reason I brought this topic up was becuase of the detailed explanation about how iodide binds excessive oxygen within the corals tissue thus removing the excessive oxygen which they are claiming to be irritating to the corals ( I've read those articles before but hadn't seen any reference to this theoretical action of removing excessive tissue irritating oxygen, but maybe I overlooked it). I was just wondering if there was new reseach to support any part of their claims or not. It was a new perspective I hadn't read before so I had to put it out there for you guys to review.

Thanks!

Jeremy
 
Jeremy

Chris Brightwell can never get his fact straight ands is so full of BS and hype

1.The predominant form of iodine in seawater is iodide.

No, it is not, it is Iodate :lol: Randy also points this out, where it is 3-4 X more Iodate than Iodide.

See

Reviews in Aquatic Science, Vol 4 Issue, 1 1991
The Marine Geocehmistry of Iodine by G.T.F. Wong

2. Iodide essentially bonds with oxygen to form non-toxic iodate

Why when it is almost all Iodate to begin with

3. We develop formulae for aquaria based on empirical data, using observation and measurement rather than theory.

He has observed Iodine getting oxidized, being taken up by corals and being passively removed by aggressive protein skimming. So, how come he never has data when asked


4. small concentration, iodine is required for survival of fishes, crustaceans

They get it from their food
 
The comment of his about iodide is such a surprising gaffe, that one wonders if it was something he actually knew was incorrect, but stated anyway so as to not "confuse" folks. Sort of a "You can't handle the truth" idea.
 
Thank you very much guys!!

Good marketing can be really terrible for consumers when there are such technical terms and complex theories being thrown around (and significantly twisted to make their product sound useful). If we didn't have you guys available to dispel the false claims within the marketing lingo, it would be pretty easy to get sucked into buying the products. Thanks for saving me some money - again and again and again and again!!!!

Jeremy
 
Back
Top