Is the new Canon XSi good for a beginner?

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=12493676#post12493676 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by beerguy
No they're not. Haven't you been paying attention?
It's kind of like DVR. It sounds like a good idea, but you don't appreciate how much until you have one.
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=12494776#post12494776 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by ChrisMc73
You Canon guys are FUNNY! Can't wait to handle one an see what makes you all so passionate about them! I'll be commenting on both...Nikon and Canon...for sure!

I will want all your inputs to my comments too, and my opinions!

Oh and I thought you Canon guys would love this...thes pictures which I consider some of the best I've seen on this forum, are taken with a Canon XTi...with f 2/8 macro lens 100mm

http://www.reefcentral.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=1343429&perpage=25&pagenumber=1

Awesome pics!

Yeah, that guy knows what hes doing with a camera.
 
Being able to have preset settings is the one and only things that's going to have me buying a new camera soon. :) Ok well and live preview...2 things! LOL!
 
Live View is a fantastic feature for doing coral macro shots. Live View is available on the Canon XSi and 40D, but not the XTi. Live View is available on the Nikon D300, but nothing lower. It is not that useful for composing normal pictures.

The Canons also come with software that lets you control all aspects of the shot from a PC connected to your camera through a USB cable (Nikon has similar software, but it costs $80 I think). Together with live view, it displays the composed picture on your computer screen before you take it. You can set it to 5x or 10x zoom and use manual focus. Great stuff for reef macro photography.

I downloaded software that scripts a technique called focus stacking. With macro photgraphy, the Depth of field is extremely small. This means (depending on aperture) only a few millimeters of a 3" deep coral may be in focus. With Focus Stacking, you take many pictures, adjusting the focus a small amount each time, and use software to merge all of the in focus areas to one shot. The software I downloaded scripted the whole process.

I also own the Canon 100mm macro, and have had an absolute blast with it and my reef tank.

I have only owned a DSLR for 2 weeks, so be nice, but here are some of my pictures. Click the picture, and then the "Download Photo" to see the full resolution version. The last one was made with the focus stacking technique (NOT a good example of it though) - but that is why it has artifacts.



This is my first attempt at a "focus stack". Be sure to click through anf hit "download photo", or it is rather ordinary:





More here:

http://picasaweb.google.com/thegreenhuts/Reef


jeff
 
Thanks - I am now using a 40D and the Canon 100mm Macro. However, these pictures were taken with the Rebel XSi and the same lens.
 
Get a camera first for SURE. Were going to want you to document your tank as you build it. As I'm sure you can see, the "what are these tiny white see through things with little antenna in my tank" threads are VERY annoying without good photos. I don't even bother answering those anymore. If you have some good macro pictures of those little white things, we (usually) can easily identify them. Taking pictures of pretty stuff you want to show off is only half of it. I also really recommend the 40D over an Xti or Xsi. If it will keep you from buying a 100 macro or 24-70, then get a rebel...but if you can afford it, an XXD is a much better camera. Buy your camera without the crappy kit lens. Once you get some real glass you'll never use it anyway.
 
Ok thanks for the advice!
I have a quote, for a AGE tank build going right now with Kingfish John, so I'll probably be spending all my profit sharing on cameras and tanks! I also want a new Mac!!!
 
It's really up to how the camera feels. To me on features (particularly for a reefer), the XSi beats the D80 on features - 3" LCD, liveview, etc. The consensus seems to be the D80 has better autofocus and "tranditional" features. The D80 has a more traditional build, and many find the XSi more "plasticky"


Also, if you want to do macro, the canon 100mm macro is much cheaper than the nikon 105 (but it has VR, which is not really useful for tripod mounted reef shots). Still, you could buy an even cheaper third part alternative for either.
 
alternatively there is the Tamron 90 w/ 1:1 (just under $500), which gets decent reviews, if you go with the nikon

the 105VR looks sweet, but its $750, which may be too much for a hobbiest

but I agree that lens selection is important when deciding on a camera
 
The D200 has the setting banks that you were asking about. The D80 does not. Yes they're useful.

The D300 also has the ability to store and restore those, just in case you make an on the fly change to the bank along the way.
 
Thanks all for the continued advice! I will be in the shop this weekend...so you'll hear my feedback.

So the LiveView feature, is that like what is on most point and shoot digital cameras now...just a live view on the LCD screen?

I guess thats nice to have...but jeez the D300 is $1700!
 
Last edited:
If you don't want to spend 1700, don't do any research on the D300. Don't even touch it. You'll have to have it. :D
 
You don't use Live View like a point and shoot does though. DSLR's use the viewfinder. For coral shots on a tripod, you can use live view to get the focus PERFECT. Reefing is really the main application I can think of a use for it. Most photographers not in this hobby have only turned it on once to say "hey there is it" and never touched it again. Macro and live view go together though.
 
Back
Top