IS this Longspine Urchin really reef safe?

Yeah. I had one for awhile in my little nano but they get big, real big. With spines, I've seen them over 12" in diameter. They eat algae (all kinds) and will chomp away at your coralline. If you like the "clean look" they're perfect. They won't hurt your corals just walk on them and maybe knock them over with their long spines. I found mine to be very agile. Check out mimosa's gallery, he has two huge ones.
 
They will, IME, unfortunately damage SPS.
Not sure if they are eating them or just "tasting" as they graze, but they definitely remove the growth tips from SPS.
 
Diadema sestosum is one of the best generalized grazers. It is a very through grazer, often grazing down through coraline algae and into the white carbonate rock. It will graze more types of algae than most grazers, but IME prefers red algae, especially red wire algae and coraline algae. There are some algae it seems to avoid, like red cotton algae (Asparagopsis) and Sargassum.

It comes small but grows quickly. It is fast-moving for an urchin and quite agile. The long spines penetrate the skin easily and break off to leave a painful tip under the skin. Several types of fish use Diadema spines as protection from predators in the wild. Larger urchins may sample certain stony coral but IME rarely do much damage. Poorly secured fragments will be knocked off by a Diadema, very small and fragile fragments could be eaten. Diadema will accept meat food like frozen Mysis shrimp. I had one Diadema trap a Mandarin while it was in its nightly stupor and kill it, eating it tail-first when I found it.

The best single herbivore I've come across. Its a beautiful and active creature that usually catches a visitor's attention.
 
I have to agree with Howard. Overall, they are nimble, useful and safe. One fo the best grazers on reefs and in aquaria alike. Just be sure you can provide an adequate tank (size) for growth in time. They get large.
 
I got several with my lr from TBS and they would actually eat my frags. I had too small a tank for they and got rid of all of them. IMO, not a good addition to a reef tank.
 
moumda: couldn't have been Diadema sestosum, as they are Pacific. There is an Atlantic Diadema but a large percentage of those were killed off by a pandemic some years back. The Atlantic Diadema has different colored spines than D. sestosum, but both have very long, thin and brittle spines. When I say "long" I mean 6 inches and longer is not unusual, much longer than most other urchins you will encounter. Many genus of urchins are prone to eat coral, maybe you got one of them?
 
Could be. they started out small and got to be softball size and got to be a pain. They did eat a lot of algea though.
 
I was 'gifted' a orphaned Long Spine and two 'carrier' urchins. The are cool to watch and in great health but they are devouring my corraline. If anybody wants them all they have to do is pay shipping and they are yours. Pm me if you are interested
 
Just another quick suggestion regarding urchins...I have light that spills into one of my built-in overflows and it always was difficult to clean the algea builtup. Then I put in an urchin and have not had to touch it again in over a year. It never quite catches up with the growth and starves but it keeps it neatly trimmed. The urchin and I both appear very happy with the accomodations.
 
I have a long spin urchin and i think its cool, i also have a few small sps frags that was only once nipped by the urchin, it generally eats coralline algea. on the other hand i have a pencil urchin that now lives in the sump. That ate absolutly everything it came across, I had a really big leather at the time and it ate right through the middle of it, I must admit though as distraught about the coral i was I did chuckle.
 
Back
Top