Looking for overflow recommendations

Jred

New member
So had a scare last night as my U-tube overflow had stopped.

Luckily no water was spilled, but it was enough to scare my wife into letting me buy something different. :D

Can anyone recommend a reasonably priced and reliable overflow? Where is the best place to buy?


Thanks!
 
over flow

over flow

I will be curious to see what responce you get.
I have one tank running 2 u tubes and worry a little.
I can say I don't have air build up any more after I went with a big pump, I'm running 2 u tubes at all they can flow.
before I had 1 with a smaller pump . air would build up in the top of the u. as soon as the flow went up all the air is flushed out.
I wish this tank was drilled in the bottom.
I have seen the flat tubes collect air and lose their siphon.

In my opinion any siphon tube running low flow is prone to stopping. I think they sell some kind of device that keeps the air out.
 
I use a CPR with an aqualifter pump to keep the siphon going. You could probably hook an aqualifter up to your u-tube setup.
 
its basically a small pump that sucks water in and pushes it out with a diaphram simialr to an airpump but with water.

Basically you would need to drill a small hole in the u-tube and install a 1/8" male fitting. The pump would then suck air/water fromt he overflow and return into the tank or sump.

Not sure where to get the right fitting though. But im sure it would work and save you a good chunk of change.
 
I've been thinking about trying that with my u-tubes because they get air in them all the time. I have to resiphon them about once a week.

The only thing I was worried about was cracking the plasic. Not very heavy duty stuff.
 
I have found the trick is having enough flow going thru the U tube to keep the bubbles from building up in the first place.
I know thats not always an option but when I was running about 300gph thru the overflow bubble would slowly build up but after switching to a larger pumprated at 800gph the water would travel so fast thru the U-tube that it would pull any bubbles thru also.
 
That's true as long as the bulkhead in the overflow is big enough to handle the extra flow. It isn't in my case.
 
I also use the CPR with the aqualifter pump. It's a very reliable combination. The other nice thing about the CPR is that it is very low profile compared to some of the U-Tube setups.

-JB
 
Thanks for all the great info everyone!

I might look into the CPR setup. Has anyone had major problems with that type of setup?
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=8837440#post8837440 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by got2lb
That's true as long as the bulkhead in the overflow is big enough to handle the extra flow. It isn't in my case.
Then a smaller U tube will also speed up the flow thru it.
 
One u-tube can't handle the flow 2 is to much. I can crank the flow up way higher than the u-tubes can even handle. What is the max flow that 1 u-tube can handle. I'm only running about 600gph now through my sump i really don't want to drop it any lower.

The CPR would be okay but make sure you get the aqualifter. They should just sell them packaged together.
 
If you don't have an aqualifter, you can also hook it up to small powerhead in your sump... I think that's why they don't sell them as a package.

-JB
 
personally i would not be too fond of drilling a hole in a u-tube. I would rather run some air hose to the apex of the u-tube, that would be connected to a pump/aqualifter.

it is kinda funny, cause i have been thinking about this very issue lately, and was thinking about going with one of those CPR's with aqualifter pumps. Mostly because i want the lower profile.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=8855507#post8855507 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by mcclandy
personally i would not be too fond of drilling a hole in a u-tube. I would rather run some air hose to the apex of the u-tube, that would be connected to a pump/aqualifter.

it is kinda funny, cause i have been thinking about this very issue lately, and was thinking about going with one of those CPR's with aqualifter pumps. Mostly because i want the lower profile.

Guess that would work too........either way it would definetly be ALOT more reliable.
 
Yeah, I am not too fond of drilling into the U-tube either at this point. I enjoy experimenting with things like that, but not without a backup.

I think I am going to try a larger return pump first and dial back any excessive flow that the u-tube can't handle. I don't quite know what the return flow is currently, but I would like a bit faster turnover.

If that doesn't work, I'll start playing with the u-tube or a CPR. I would like to have a backup pump anyway.

So what would be a good return pump and how much gph do you think the U-tube can handle? My current pump is submersible, should I consider an external?
 
u tube

u tube

I have a 75 gallon with a mag 7 untill I ran 1" pvc ,the over flow box ran just fine, as soon as I ran the 1" the purchased box would not keep up with the flow. I had to put a valve and slightly
choke it back.
you did not say what size line you have from the pump but it does not take much of a restriction to reduce the flow rate
 
Back
Top